[Fix] (Magma): decline programs whose final SPIR-V fails validation instead of handing the module to the driver

This commit is contained in:
2026-10-02 23:09:58 -04:00
parent b64c2de3c8
commit bfa7987ca6
11 changed files with 380 additions and 19 deletions
@@ -391,6 +391,15 @@ namespace MobileGL::MG_Backend::DirectVulkan {
VkPipeline PipelineFactory::CreatePipeline(const PipelineCreatePayload& payload) const {
MOBILEGL_ASSERT(payload.stages != nullptr && !payload.stages->empty(), "PipelineFactory: stages are empty");
// The assert compiles out of shipping builds, and a program declined for an invalid
// module (VkProgramObject::invalidSpirvDeclined) has no stages at all: a caller that
// forgot to refuse it must get a skipped draw, not a stageCount=0 pipeline.
if (payload.stages == nullptr || payload.stages->empty()) {
MGLOG_E_ONCE("PipelineFactory::CreatePipeline: refusing a pipeline with no shader stages "
"(programHash=0x%llx); its draws are skipped",
static_cast<unsigned long long>(payload.programHash));
return VK_NULL_HANDLE;
}
MOBILEGL_ASSERT(payload.vertexInputState != nullptr, "PipelineFactory: vertexInputState is null");
MOBILEGL_ASSERT(payload.pipelineLayout != VK_NULL_HANDLE, "PipelineFactory: pipelineLayout is null");
MOBILEGL_ASSERT(payload.renderPass != VK_NULL_HANDLE, "PipelineFactory: renderPass is null");
@@ -12,7 +12,9 @@
#include "MG_Util/ShaderTranspiler/ShaderCompiler.h"
#include "MG_Util/ShaderTranspiler/SpvcSession.h"
#include "MG_Util/ShaderTranspiler/Types.h"
#include <Config.h>
#include <algorithm>
#include <atomic>
#include <bit>
#include <cmath>
#include <cstring>
@@ -2273,8 +2275,84 @@ namespace MobileGL::MG_Backend::DirectVulkan {
return false;
}
}
// ScreenModuleForDriver's memory. Keyed by content, never by program: the same bytes get
// the same answer whichever program, variant or session carries them.
struct DriverModuleVerdictCache {
struct Entry {
Uint64 wordCount = 0;
Bool valid = true;
String reason;
};
// Generous for any one application's distinct stage modules; past it the whole table
// is dropped rather than tracked per entry - a re-validation is the only cost.
static constexpr SizeT kMaxEntries = 8192;
std::mutex mutex;
UnorderedMap<Uint64, Entry> entries;
std::atomic<Uint64> validatorRuns{0};
};
DriverModuleVerdictCache& GetDriverModuleVerdictCache() {
// Leaked on purpose: screened from session threads that may outlive static destruction.
static auto* cache = new DriverModuleVerdictCache();
return *cache;
}
} // namespace
ProgramFactory::DriverModuleVerdict ProgramFactory::ScreenModuleForDriver(const Vector<Uint>& spirv,
Bool allowInvalid, String* outReason) {
if (outReason != nullptr) outReason->clear();
if (spirv.empty()) return DriverModuleVerdict::Valid;
auto& cache = GetDriverModuleVerdictCache();
const Uint64 key = XXH64(spirv.data(), spirv.size() * sizeof(Uint), 0);
Bool valid = true;
String reason;
Bool known = false;
{
const std::lock_guard<std::mutex> lock(cache.mutex);
const auto it = cache.entries.find(key);
if (it != cache.entries.end() && it->second.wordCount == spirv.size()) {
known = true;
valid = it->second.valid;
reason = it->second.reason;
}
}
if (!known) {
// Outside the lock: two threads screening the same new module both validate, and
// agree; nothing waits on another session's spirv-val.
MG_Util::ShaderTranspiler::ShaderCompiler::PrepareSpirvValidation();
cache.validatorRuns.fetch_add(1, std::memory_order_relaxed);
spv_context context = spvContextCreate(GetSpirvTargetEnv(spirv));
spv_validator_options options = spvValidatorOptionsCreate();
spvValidatorOptionsSetFriendlyNames(options, true);
spv_const_binary_t binary = {spirv.data(), spirv.size()};
spv_diagnostic diagnostic = nullptr;
const spv_result_t result = spvValidateWithOptions(context, options, &binary, &diagnostic);
valid = result == SPV_SUCCESS;
if (!valid) {
reason = diagnostic != nullptr && diagnostic->error != nullptr ? diagnostic->error : "<no diagnostic>";
// The process-wide counter the validating test lanes assert on.
MG_Util::ShaderTranspiler::ShaderCompiler::NoteSpirvValidationFailure();
}
spvDiagnosticDestroy(diagnostic);
spvValidatorOptionsDestroy(options);
spvContextDestroy(context);
const std::lock_guard<std::mutex> lock(cache.mutex);
if (cache.entries.size() >= DriverModuleVerdictCache::kMaxEntries) cache.entries.clear();
cache.entries[key] = DriverModuleVerdictCache::Entry{spirv.size(), valid, reason};
}
if (valid) return DriverModuleVerdict::Valid;
if (outReason != nullptr) *outReason = Move(reason);
return allowInvalid ? DriverModuleVerdict::AdmittedInvalid : DriverModuleVerdict::DeclinedInvalid;
}
Uint64 ProgramFactory::DriverModuleValidatorRuns() {
return GetDriverModuleVerdictCache().validatorRuns.load(std::memory_order_relaxed);
}
// A shader that assigns gl_FragDepth (SPIR-V DepthReplacing) supplies depth itself
// instead of taking the pipeline's interpolated Z, so a driver that varies the vertex
// position math between pipelines cannot desynchronize it; the blended depth-write
@@ -3814,27 +3892,42 @@ namespace MobileGL::MG_Backend::DirectVulkan {
const Bool remapOk = RemapDescriptorBindingsForVulkan(moduleSpirvs, m_maxBindings, moduleSpirvs);
MOBILEGL_ASSERT(remapOk, "ProgramFactory::GetOrCreateProgram: descriptor binding remap failed");
// Last look at the exact bytes the driver receives, in EVERY build rather than only in
// DEBUG or with MOBILEGL_ENABLE_SPIRV_VALIDATION armed, and for every stage BEFORE any
// module is created. By here the descriptor bindings have been remapped and the layout
// about to be reflected describes the remapped module, so there is no module left that
// is both valid and consistent with it to fall back to (the recovery that exists lives
// one step earlier, at the clip/XFB fixups). What is left is to keep the bytes away from
// the driver: a driver is not a validating entry point, and an invalid module it accepts
// can fault the GPU into device loss (a frontend translation once put a sampler inside
// the default uniform block, and Adreno page-faulted reading its "descriptor" out of
// uniform-buffer bytes). One invalid stage declines the whole program: no shader module
// of it is created, and every draw or dispatch of it is refused by name
// (VkProgramObject::invalidSpirvDeclined). MOBILEGL_MAGMA_ALLOW_INVALID_SPIRV hands the
// bytes over anyway, for diagnosing a driver that copes.
for (SizeT i = 0; i < moduleCount; ++i) {
String reason;
const DriverModuleVerdict verdict = ScreenModuleForDriver(
moduleSpirvs[i], MG_Config::Features.MagmaAllowInvalidSpirv, &reason);
if (verdict == DriverModuleVerdict::DeclinedInvalid) {
MGLOG_E_ONCE("ProgramFactory: declining program %u - its stage %d module fails SPIR-V validation (%s); "
"no shader module is created and its draws are refused. "
"MOBILEGL_MAGMA_ALLOW_INVALID_SPIRV=1 hands such modules to the driver anyway.",
program.GetExternalIndex(), static_cast<Int>(stages[i]), reason.c_str());
entry.invalidSpirvDeclined = true;
break;
}
if (verdict == DriverModuleVerdict::AdmittedInvalid) {
MGLOG_E_ONCE("ProgramFactory: handing vkCreateShaderModule an INVALID module for program %u stage %d "
"because MOBILEGL_MAGMA_ALLOW_INVALID_SPIRV is set (%s)",
program.GetExternalIndex(), static_cast<Int>(stages[i]), reason.c_str());
}
}
for (SizeT i = 0; i < moduleCount && !entry.invalidSpirvDeclined; ++i) {
auto& moduleSpv = moduleSpirvs[i];
if (moduleSpv.empty()) continue;
// Last look at the exact bytes the driver receives, in EVERY build rather than only
// in DEBUG or with MOBILEGL_ENABLE_SPIRV_VALIDATION armed. This one only reports:
// by here the descriptor bindings have been remapped and the layout about to be
// reflected describes the remapped module, so there is no module left that is both
// valid and consistent with it to fall back to. The recovery lives one step earlier,
// at the clip/XFB fixups (see the revert there) - which is where a transform can
// introduce a reference to a delisted interface variable, the failure this whole
// guard exists for. Anything that reaches this line names itself in the log of a
// shipping build instead of dying anonymously inside the driver.
SpirvValidationFailure finalFailure{};
if (!ValidateTransformedSpirv(moduleSpv, stages[i], program.GetExternalIndex(), &finalFailure)) {
MGLOG_E_ONCE("ProgramFactory: handing vkCreateShaderModule an INVALID module for program %u stage %d - "
"a backend transform after the clip/XFB fixups broke it (%s)",
program.GetExternalIndex(), static_cast<Int>(stages[i]),
finalFailure.message.c_str());
}
// Does the stage the driver will treat as the last pre-rasterization one actually
// carry Xfb? Asked of the FINAL bytes, so it answers for whatever the whole transform
// chain produced - a rewound clip/XFB backstop, a capture pass that resolved no
@@ -229,6 +229,11 @@ namespace MobileGL::MG_Backend::DirectVulkan {
// the cache entry, so every later draw of the same program variant reads the same
// answer instead of re-deciding it.
Bool pointSizeCapabilityUnsupported = false;
// One of the program's final modules fails SPIR-V validation, so none of its modules
// was created and every draw or dispatch of it is refused by name (the ProgramInvalidSpirv /
// ComputeProgramInvalidSpirv wire declines) - see ProgramFactory::ScreenModuleForDriver.
// Sticky like the flag above: it lives on the cache entry, so the one log line is honest.
Bool invalidSpirvDeclined = false;
Bool needsPassthroughTessControl = false;
// ...and the pass-through this renderer can synthesize carries gl_Position and
// nothing else, so it is only correct when the evaluation stage's inputs are
@@ -289,6 +294,11 @@ namespace MobileGL::MG_Backend::DirectVulkan {
storageBlockIndexByBinding = std::move(other.storageBlockIndexByBinding);
hasStorageImages = other.hasStorageImages;
declinedDescriptors = other.declinedDescriptors;
// The three refusal flags travel like every other field: a robin-hood insert swaps
// entries, and a flag left behind would refuse (or admit) the wrong program.
invalidSpirvDeclined = other.invalidSpirvDeclined;
xfbCaptureDeclined = other.xfbCaptureDeclined;
pointSizeCapabilityUnsupported = other.pointSizeCapabilityUnsupported;
globalUboBinding = other.globalUboBinding;
activeVertexInputLocationMask = other.activeVertexInputLocationMask;
vertexInputTypes = other.vertexInputTypes;
@@ -310,6 +320,9 @@ namespace MobileGL::MG_Backend::DirectVulkan {
other.pipelineLayout = VK_NULL_HANDLE;
other.hasStorageImages = false;
other.declinedDescriptors = false;
other.invalidSpirvDeclined = false;
other.xfbCaptureDeclined = false;
other.pointSizeCapabilityUnsupported = false;
other.globalUboBinding = -1;
other.activeVertexInputLocationMask = 0;
other.activeFragmentOutputLocationMask = 0;
@@ -353,6 +366,11 @@ namespace MobileGL::MG_Backend::DirectVulkan {
storageBlockIndexByBinding = std::move(other.storageBlockIndexByBinding);
hasStorageImages = other.hasStorageImages;
declinedDescriptors = other.declinedDescriptors;
// The three refusal flags travel like every other field: a robin-hood insert swaps
// entries, and a flag left behind would refuse (or admit) the wrong program.
invalidSpirvDeclined = other.invalidSpirvDeclined;
xfbCaptureDeclined = other.xfbCaptureDeclined;
pointSizeCapabilityUnsupported = other.pointSizeCapabilityUnsupported;
globalUboBinding = other.globalUboBinding;
activeVertexInputLocationMask = other.activeVertexInputLocationMask;
vertexInputTypes = other.vertexInputTypes;
@@ -374,6 +392,9 @@ namespace MobileGL::MG_Backend::DirectVulkan {
other.pipelineLayout = VK_NULL_HANDLE;
other.hasStorageImages = false;
other.declinedDescriptors = false;
other.invalidSpirvDeclined = false;
other.xfbCaptureDeclined = false;
other.pointSizeCapabilityUnsupported = false;
other.globalUboBinding = -1;
other.activeVertexInputLocationMask = 0;
other.activeFragmentOutputLocationMask = 0;
@@ -504,6 +525,29 @@ namespace MobileGL::MG_Backend::DirectVulkan {
// VkRenderPassManager::OnPresent's sweep.
void OnFrameBoundary();
// What the last look at a module's final bytes - the exact words vkCreateShaderModule
// would receive - decided.
enum class DriverModuleVerdict : Uint8 {
Valid, // validates: handed to the driver
DeclinedInvalid, // fails validation: never handed over, the program's work is declined
AdmittedInvalid, // fails validation, handed over anyway (MOBILEGL_MAGMA_ALLOW_INVALID_SPIRV)
};
// Validates `spirv` for the Vulkan environment its version word names and turns the
// result into a verdict. A driver is not a validating entry point: Adreno page-faulted
// into device loss on a module that carried a sampler inside a uniform block, Mali
// SIGSEGVs inside pipeline creation. So an invalid module is declined unless
// `allowInvalid` (the escape hatch) says to hand it over regardless.
//
// The validator's answer is remembered per module content (64-bit hash plus word count),
// process-wide: a program variant, an evicted-then-rebuilt entry and two programs that
// share a stage all re-screen the same bytes, and only the first pays for spirv-val.
// `outReason` receives the validator's message for an invalid module.
static DriverModuleVerdict ScreenModuleForDriver(const Vector<Uint>& spirv, Bool allowInvalid,
String* outReason = nullptr);
// How many times ScreenModuleForDriver actually ran the validator (cache misses), for
// the tests that pin the cache.
static Uint64 DriverModuleValidatorRuns();
static VkShaderStageFlagBits ToVkStage(ShaderStage stage);
static VkFormat ConvertSpirvImageFormatToVkFormat(SpvImageFormat format);
static SamplerNumericDomain UniformTypeToSamplerNumericDomain(GLenum glType);
@@ -6835,7 +6835,7 @@ void main() {
// A refused program cannot reach here today - the full path refuses before it ever
// records a snapshot - but declining the fast path costs one compare and means the
// refusal does not depend on that ordering staying true.
if (programObj.pointSizeCapabilityUnsupported) {
if (programObj.pointSizeCapabilityUnsupported || programObj.invalidSpirvDeclined) {
return false;
}
@@ -7318,7 +7318,7 @@ void main() {
// The build already said why, once, naming the program and the stage. Refusing here -
// before any pipeline is built from it - is what makes that message a decline rather
// than a note attached to invalid usage the driver still receives.
if (programObj.pointSizeCapabilityUnsupported) {
if (programObj.pointSizeCapabilityUnsupported || programObj.invalidSpirvDeclined) {
return false;
}
// For the snapshot's memoised entry pointer: if anything below inserts into the
@@ -7778,6 +7778,8 @@ void main() {
}
ProgramFactory::CompileOptionFlags transformFlags = 0;
const auto& programObj = m_programFactory->GetOrCreateProgram(program, transformFlags);
// No shader module of a program that failed validation exists; the build said why, once.
if (programObj.invalidSpirvDeclined) return;
if (!frame.isCommandRecording) {
m_frameContext.BeginCommandRecording();
@@ -7840,6 +7842,8 @@ void main() {
}
ProgramFactory::CompileOptionFlags transformFlags = 0;
const auto& programObj = m_programFactory->GetOrCreateProgram(program, transformFlags);
// No shader module of a program that failed validation exists; the build said why, once.
if (programObj.invalidSpirvDeclined) return;
if (!frame.isCommandRecording) {
m_frameContext.BeginCommandRecording();
@@ -126,3 +126,11 @@ MGL_WIRE_DECLINE(MipmapDepthStencilAspect)
// is missing, or the three group-count words lie outside it or are misaligned.
MGL_WIRE_DECLINE(DispatchIndirectBufferUnbound)
MGL_WIRE_DECLINE(DispatchIndirectRange)
// ---- ProgramFactory::ScreenModuleForDriver ------------------------------------------------
// One of the bound program's final modules fails SPIR-V validation, so no shader module of it was
// created (VkProgramObject::invalidSpirvDeclined): SetupWireDraw refuses the draw, and the two
// dispatch arms the dispatch. A driver handed the module could fault the GPU into device loss.
// MOBILEGL_MAGMA_ALLOW_INVALID_SPIRV=1 builds the module anyway, and then neither row moves.
MGL_WIRE_DECLINE(ProgramInvalidSpirv)
MGL_WIRE_DECLINE(ComputeProgramInvalidSpirv)
@@ -230,6 +230,10 @@
flags |= ProgramFactory::CompileOptionBit::ZeroBaseVertex;
programObject = &m_programFactory->GetOrCreateProgram(program, flags);
}
if (programObject->invalidSpirvDeclined) {
MGL_WIRE_DECLINE_AT(ProgramInvalidSpirv, "a module of the program fails SPIR-V validation and was never built");
return false;
}
if (programObject->pointSizeCapabilityUnsupported) {
MGL_WIRE_DECLINE_AT(PointSizeCapability, "the program writes gl_PointSize and the device cannot express it");
return false;
@@ -775,6 +779,10 @@
return;
}
const auto& programObj = m_programFactory->GetOrCreateProgram(program, {});
if (programObj.invalidSpirvDeclined) {
MGL_WIRE_DECLINE_AT(ComputeProgramInvalidSpirv, "a module of the compute program fails SPIR-V validation and was never built");
return;
}
if (!m_uniformManager->PrepareWireTextureResources(program, programObj)) {
MGL_WIRE_DECLINE_AT(ComputeTextureResourcesUnprepared, "a sampled/storage image could not be made ready for the dispatch");
return;
@@ -847,6 +855,10 @@
return;
}
const auto& programObj = m_programFactory->GetOrCreateProgram(program, {});
if (programObj.invalidSpirvDeclined) {
MGL_WIRE_DECLINE_AT(ComputeProgramInvalidSpirv, "a module of the compute program fails SPIR-V validation and was never built");
return;
}
if (!m_uniformManager->PrepareWireTextureResources(program, programObj)) {
MGL_WIRE_DECLINE_AT(ComputeTextureResourcesUnprepared, "a sampled/storage image could not be made ready for the dispatch");
return;