Commit Graph
5 Commits
Author SHA1 Message Date
BZLZHH b1ef484116 [Perf] (MG_Remote): the residency budget does not make the window usable either - the answer is gone before the client next looks, so a deferral needs RETENTION, not a budget
Steps 1 and 2 of the plan the design review set out, landed and measured on the
device. Step 1 answers the question step 2 depended on; step 2 answers the one the
whole line depended on, and the answer is that the window's shape is wrong.

STEP 1 - CAN AN ANSWER BE LOST IN DELIVERY? NO. ReplyPool now counts what the link
took (PostedReplies) and what it refused (FailedReplies), and a non-OK result is
NAMED instead of swallowed: it checked only BUFFER_TOO_SMALL and let
TRANSPORT_CLOSED vanish with no line and no counter, so "the server never sent it"
and "it was sent and the buffer overwrote it" were the same symptom with opposite
fixes. Measured: posted=4501 failed=0. The twenty-answer gap between the server's
tally and the client's was a sampling difference, not a drop - and the server's
m_answered counts ATTEMPTS (incremented before PostReply), which is why it could
never have settled it.

STEP 2 - DOES A RESIDENCY BUDGET FIX THE WINDOW? NO.
Wire_ResourceCreate now measures how many reply-owning records the client has
emitted since the oldest window entry was pushed (ClientSession::ReplyPostings, a
new clock) and takes the oldest answer back as soon as that approaches the reply
buffer's depth, instead of deferring past the point where the answer can still
exist. On the device:

    P12win call=4501 cfg=2 eff=2 pending=2 taken=63 pushed=65 blocked=4435
           budget=4451 readfail=8872 posts=54377
    kind=frame-op frame=14 wait_replies=9078 by_op=2=9071   wall 27.87 s

budget=4451: it fires on essentially EVERY create, the window stops deferring
(pushed=65), and the drain still reads nothing back. THE REASON IS STRUCTURAL, not
a constant:

  * the window only gets control WHEN A CREATE ARRIVES. Between two creates this
    client emits on the order of a thousand records - at the FIRST failed read the
    reply ring already spanned [1175..1504] while the head was seq 310 - and nothing
    looks at the window in that gap;
  * what displaces a deferred answer is not what this client emits, it is WHAT THE
    SERVER ANSWERS. The server is the one behind (one answer per ~5 ms wakeup while
    the client runs ahead), so the replies arriving during the gap are its LATE
    ANSWERS TO THE EARLIER CREATES - they fill the 8 slots first;
  * so the check fires too late by construction. Tightening it does not fix that; it
    only removes the deferral entirely, which is what pushed=65 is.

WHAT THAT LEAVES. A deferral is readable only if the client KEEPS the answers it
deferred. The buffer is bounded by COUNT and the client cannot bound how many
answers the server will post between two of its creates, so hoping the buffer still
holds one is a race the client loses - which is also why the earlier two diagnoses
(reply-pool churn, then FIFO-with-no-way-out) were both describing symptoms of the
same thing. The shape that can work is retention: the reader keeps the answers for
the seqs still outstanding (a handful), drops them when read, and reports a LOSS
when a read asks for one it no longer has. That is a transport change - StreamLink's
ring becomes a retention map with a cap and a lost counter - and it is the next step.

BOTH STEPS STAY: step 1 is a net gain on its own, and step 2 is the safe direction
(it can only degrade the window to no-deferral, i.e. the pre-window shape) and its
clock is the one the retention design needs. MOBILEGL_IPC_CREATE_WINDOW stays at 1.

172/172 and 13/13 after the probes were removed. The measurements and the revised
conclusion are in notes/p12/CREATE-WINDOW-MEASURED.md section 9.
2026-09-26 02:35:05 +08:00
BZLZHH 4e48702f26 [Feat] (MG_Remote): a record can tell the server its answer will never be read - the bit works and cuts a frame's replies by 92%, and it proves the window's real blocker is the FIFO drain, not the pool depth
The create window could not collect its deferred answers. The previous commit
diagnosed that as the reply pool being 8 slots deep against 55,903 replies in one
frame, and left a no-reply bit as the way out. This lands that bit, measures it on
the device, and reports that the diagnosis was half wrong.

WHAT LANDED. ClientSession::EmitAndWaitTails takes a second question beside
wantReply: willReadReply. They are not the same question and the window is the case
that separates them - it emits with wantReply=false and READS the answer later, so
its records must still be answered. kRecNoReply (RingRecordFlags bit 5, which
aliases kOptional in the call-flag space; the flag-space asserts were extended and
the alias named) is stamped when willReadReply is false, and the decoder skips
PostReply while keeping every acceptance counter - "nobody reads the answer" is not
"nothing happened". The two illegal combinations are Fatal by name.

Three call sites say it: SetTextureParams for a confirmed object, the respecify
row's fire-and-forget half, and sub-data where MGPipeSubDataWantsItsReply decides.

MEASURED ON THE DEVICE (aikjs4s8cys8ba7l, rebuilt APK + client, both halves new):
    server:  skipped=50,001   answered=4,521        (a frame's replies: 55,903 -> 4,543)
    client:  Reply frames received seen=4,501, latest seq=97,181
    frame-sent: identical per op, records untouched
    create row: by_op 2 = 9,070 (was 4,536)  - because the drain's blocking take is
               now counted, so the row's number stays honest instead of reading as
               "create stopped waiting" while the waiting merely moved
AND THE WINDOW STILL READ BACK NOTHING: readfail 8,951 -> 8,872, i.e. -0.9%.

THE REAL CAUSE, from the miss probe:
    P12miss n=1     want=310 replySeq=1504   ring=[1175..1504]
    P12miss n=9001  want=310 replySeq=102915 ring=[102866..102915]
want=310 every time. The drain is STRICTLY FIFO and a failed read has no way out -
it retries the same head for ever. Any reply buffer is bounded by design (8 pool
slots, or the 8-frame ring the stream link now keeps), so with 4,536 deferred
answers at least one is overwritten before it is read, and that one wedges the
window permanently. Cutting the churn by two orders of magnitude does not help: it
turns a certainty into a certainty. That is the constraint, not the depth.

THE FIX IS NAMED AND NOT TAKEN (the goal this work ran under stops here on purpose).
On a failed read of the head, abandon it: MGPipeNoteHandleUnpublished +
NoteCreateSuspect + pop - the DECLINE path reused for "unknown". The window then
self-heals through the blocking path and the object merely gets slower. It needs its
own gate: a failed read must let the window ADVANCE.

Gates, all green (172 + 13 + 22 + 103):
  PipeWireCodecTest.TheNoReplyBitSkipsTheAnswerAndKeepsTheAcceptanceRecord - the skip,
    the kept tally, the answered/skipped split, and the negative control that a record
    WITHOUT the bit is still answered (a server that stopped answering everything
    would otherwise pass)
  RemoteClientControls.ACreateWindowDefersTheAnswersAndTheWindowOffDoesNot - now also
    asserts the answers CAME BACK (answers_taken=11, outstanding=1, fallbacks=0 against
    12 records). RED-ONCE PROVED: giving the window's creates the literal
    "fire-and-forget => skip" predicate makes this case fail.
  RingTest - the sixth and last flag alias, and the hand-written exhaustiveness list
    extended (with a note that it is only as exhaustive as that list).
  Server side: AnsweredRecords()/SkippedAnswers() - the number that made this
    debuggable, since a wire change whose effect is invisible is undebuggable.

Client-first is safe: an old server ignores bit 5 and replies as before, so the two
cross-version directions degrade to today's behaviour - this is "both ends must
upgrade to take EFFECT", not "to avoid breaking". Hit that in practice first.
2026-09-26 02:00:44 +08:00
BZLZHH 7c822cdc85 [Docs] (P12): the no-reply flag reviewed - the arithmetic holds and the flag is cheap, but the predicate has to be "this answer will never be read", not "fire-and-forget"
An independent review of the one design door the measurement left open (stop sending
the ~51,000 answers nobody reads, so the 8-slot pool stops churning and the create
window becomes collectable). Verdict: feasible, worth doing, and the proposal AS
WRITTEN would disable the thing it exists to enable.

THE CATCH. The windowed create is wantReply=false AND its answer is read -
WireTables.cpp's drain reads exactly those seqs. A bit keyed on "fire-and-forget"
therefore stops the server answering the creates the window is waiting for: the
window goes from "cannot be collected" to "there is nothing to collect", and the
readfail counter that is the only way to diagnose it disappears with it. It fails
silently, not loudly. The predicate has to be per-record "this answer will never be
read" - true of params / respecify-escape / sub-data, false of a windowed create -
carried as a separate input from wantReply (willReadReply), with
willReadReply && !rowCarriesReplySlot rejected rather than ignored.

VERIFIED HERE, not taken on trust (the reviewer's file:line claims, checked):
  - the flag space is RingRecordFlags (Ring.h:281-285), bits 0-4 taken, BIT 5 FREE,
    and the header's own table (PipeWire.inc:35-65) says "bit 5 kOptional vs (nothing)
    no ring counterpart" - so a new ring bit aliases kOptional, which is exactly what
    the assert at PipeWireCodec.cpp:142-145 refuses;
  - the three static_asserts that will trip are real and deliberate
    (PipeWireCodec.cpp:106, :142-145, RingTest.cpp:740);
  - WireFingerprint mixes payload-layout, catalogue, render-state digests + OpCount,
    none of which a ring bit moves - so no protocol revision bump is required, and
    both cross-version directions degrade to today's behaviour. That makes this
    "must upgrade both ends to take EFFECT", not "must upgrade both ends not to
    BREAK" - one notch cheaper than handoff-2 section 3.2's protocol surface;
  - StreamLink.cpp:564-571 is the independent progress flush (>= 64 records or
    >= 1 ms) and :577 is PostReply piggybacking SendProgress on the reply - so
    skipping replies coarsens progress granularity. Bounded, but unmeasured.

AND IT CORRECTED TWO OF MY OWN NUMBERS. The frame's reply count is 55,903, not
59,673: op 4 ResourceDestroy carries kNone in the catalogue (PipeWire.inc:179) and
PostReply Fatals on a row with no kReplySlot, so it never answers - I had added its
3,770 records to the total. The derived figures move with it (12.3 replies per create,
0.65 of a create of survival, 6,988 pool churns), and every copy is fixed here:
Config.h, ConfigLoader.cpp, WireTables.cpp's section comment, CONTRACT-P5E.md,
CREATE-WINDOW-MEASURED.md.

TWO MORE THINGS THE FOLLOW-UP MUST CARRY, both recorded in the note's section 7:
  - LinkMetricsBeginReply counts ownsReplySlot, so once the flag lands by_op 2 falls
    to ~0 - and section 1 of the note tells the reader to use by_op 2 to check whether
    the window engaged. That check becomes a FALSE GREEN; the flag needs a
    server-side "how many times did this op answer" counter beside it.
  - the ~112,000 sendmsg/frame the flag removes are on the apply thread, so the
    flag's own value is a measurable claim that nobody has measured.

172/172 and 13/13 after the comment corrections.
2026-09-26 01:13:31 +08:00
BZLZHH 7205509a9a [Docs] (P12): the create window is dead by arithmetic, and the two debts it exposed (the applier can no longer say it dropped a record; the picture still has no real control) 2026-09-26 00:51:56 +08:00
BZLZHH d2efd1d79d [Perf] (MG_Remote/Client): the create window lands OFF - the deferral cannot be collected, 8 reply slots against 59,673 replies in one frame - measured on the device at 4,536 blocking creates either way
The window was the handoff's remaining item: let up to N resource_create answers be
outstanding, read a provisional accept, collect the answers in order, and un-latch an
object whose late answer is DECLINED. It is a sound mechanism and the gates below pin
it - and on the device it does nothing at all, which is why the default is 1.

MEASURED, same device, same frame, same 101,421,396 B staged, same binary:

    MOBILEGL_IPC_CREATE_WINDOW=4   by_op 2 = 4,536   wall 28.64 s
    MOBILEGL_IPC_CREATE_WINDOW=1   by_op 2 = 4,536   wall 28.64 s
    (the handoff's pre-window baseline: 31.3 s)

by_op 2 counts the creates that took the BLOCKING path (LinkMetricsBeginReply is
called with ownsReplySlot = rowCarriesReplySlot && wantReply), so it not moving means
no create deferred. A temporary counter in the row said why: pushed=24, blocked=4,476,
took=20, readfail=8,951, pending pinned at 4 - the drain READ the answers back and
failed every time.

WHY, IN THE PROTOCOL'S OWN ARITHMETIC. An answer is readable only until its pool slot
is reused, and the pool is kDefaultReplySlotCount = 8. The server answers EVERY
reply-owning record, not only the rows that wait, because it cannot know which those
are (ClientSession.cpp:1897-1900: "The server posts either way"). This frame posts
59,673 of them: create 4,536 + respecify 20,633 + params 18,056 + sub-data 12,671 +
the rest. 8 slots against 59,673 replies churns 7,459 times per frame, i.e. 13.2
replies between two creates, so an answer is overwritten after 8 replies - 0.61 of a
create. The deferral is not slow, it is UNREADABLE, and no window depth fixes that.

AND IT IS NOT NEUTRAL: with the window on, the provisional accept latches an object
the applier may have refused, and the un-latch that corrects it lives in that same
unreadable drain. A refusal would become an object the client believes is published -
the silent divergence the suspect list exists to prevent. So the machinery is kept
(one experiment away from usable: a deeper pool, or a "do not answer me" bit, both
wire changes) and the default is off.

Worktree note: the window implementation itself was uncommitted in the tree at
82ed1df9 (MOBILEGL-CS-HANDOFF-2.md section 2, "can compile, gates mostly green, never
run on a device"). This commit lands it in the state the measurement supports. The
row also gains the heal the suspect list was missing - a BLOCKING create that lands
takes its object back out of it, or kCreateSuspectMax recoveries would retire the
window for the rest of the process - and the clamp that ties the environment's value
to the array, with a static_assert tying the array to half the reply pool so "someone
raises kCreateWindowMax to 8 and steps on the pool" is a compile error.

Gates (RemoteClientControls.inc), all green, 171/171 RemoteClientTest:
  ACreateWindowDefersTheAnswersAndTheWindowOffDoesNot - window on = 12 records 0 waits;
    the SAME CHILD turns the knob to 1 and it is 12 records 12 waits (the negative
    control); pending <= effective after every create; 99 clamps to the array; the
    array is <= half the pool
  ARefusedCreateUnlatchesItsObjectAndItsNextCreateBlocks - a real refusal (the
    server's consumed mask narrowed) clears the latch, +1 suspect, the object's next
    create BLOCKS (2 records 2 waits), and restoring the consumer HEALS it (latch
    back, suspect -1)

Docs: CONTRACT-P5E.md section 2.5 rewritten (it still said all three rows keep
kWaitReply), plus
docs/Disaggregated/notes/p12/CREATE-WINDOW-MEASURED.md (the numbers, the arithmetic,
the picture evidence: both arms SSIM 0.977) and
docs/Disaggregated/notes/p12/UNPUBLISH-GUARD-SIGNALS.md (handoff section 3: neither
caps generation nor FreshlyPrimed is a signal for "the applier dropped its records",
and the residual gap is one line - the dedup at TextureEmit.h:838 does not read the
latch, so an UNCHANGED descriptor after a drop produces no record and therefore no
refusal to self-heal from).
2026-09-26 00:47:19 +08:00