# i1 — image / compute / barrier / copy-image / storage block, v1 Branch `p5b/i1`, forked from `feat/disaggregated @ f5676103` (c0b's head). Worktree `~/w7/p5b-i1`. Nothing pushed; nothing merged into the integration branch. ``` 734287ac [Feat] (MG_Remote, P5b): emit i1 seven image/compute/barrier/copy-image/storage-block slots as class B and give each ServerVerbSink body the backend call the contract names b82c63a9 [Feat] (MG_Pipe, DirectGLES, P5b): move GetProgramForDispatch FATAL to BARRIER_PULLED now that compute crosses, and skip the copy-image shadow mirror under a non-monolith transport a72a96d8 [Test] (MG_Test, MG_IntegrationTest, P5b): pin i1 seven class-B slots and the served compute program, and arm 24 inproc lane entries whose results only exist if the records crossed e352e9a6 [Merge] (P5b, i1): merge feat/disaggregated at 37fc4fdb (x2 via x2m, ID-65) into p5b/i1 ``` Range **`734287ac..e352e9a6`** (three single-line commits plus the merge). `feat/disaggregated` moved to `37fc4fdb` while i1 ran (x2 via x2m); merged, no conflicts, although x2m also edits `EmitTables.cpp` (+157) — the merge is textually clean and the whole gate was re-run on the merged head. Working tree clean; the worktree's submodule symlinks are left OFF (git-safe). --- ## 1. What landed, per slot Seven slots moved class C → B: the five the census measured plus the two companions that share their rows. `kEmittedSlotsI1 = 0 → 7`, `MGR_UNMIGRATED_I1_SLOTS` is now the empty macro, and `UnmigratedSlotCount()` is 64 → 57 / `ImplementedVerbCount()` 5 → 12. | slot (census entries) | row (op) | emitter | sink body | proven by | |---|---|---|---|---| | `BindImageTexture` (138) | `bind_shader_image` (72) | `EmitBindImageTexture`: GL args verbatim, `Res` from the unit's `ImageTextureBinding`, `Access` the GL token | `OnBindShaderImage` → `GL.BindImageTexture(Unit, GlName, Level, Layered, Layer, Access, Format)` | 138 → 0 aborts; 13 `UnboundImageDescriptorScenario` lane entries | | `DispatchCompute` (49) | `launch_grid` (60) | `EmitDispatchCompute`, b1's hook order kept verbatim from the stub (`PushPersistentMapsBeforeVerb(); MarkGpuWritesForDispatch();` then the record) | `OnLaunchGrid` → `GL.DispatchCompute(GridX,Y,Z)` | 49 → 0; 3 `AtomicCounterScenario` lane entries | | `DispatchComputeIndirect` (companion) | `launch_grid` (60) | `IsIndirect = 1`, `IndirectOffset = indirect`, `IndirectBuffer` = the bound `GL_DISPATCH_INDIRECT_BUFFER` handle | `OnLaunchGrid` → `GL.DispatchComputeIndirect(IndirectOffset)` | unit: the two slots are not one thunk | | `MemoryBarrier` (18) | `memory_barrier` (61) | `EmitMemoryBarrier`, bits verbatim, no client-side lowering | `OnMemoryBarrier` → `GL.MemoryBarrier(Bits)` | 18 → 0 | | `MemoryBarrierByRegion` (companion) | `memory_barrier` (61) | `ByRegion = 1` | `OnMemoryBarrier` → `GL.MemoryBarrierByRegion(Bits)` | unit | | `CopyImageSubData` (30) | `resource_copy_region` (53) | `EmitCopyImageSubData`: handles + the two GL names + the targets verbatim; a renderbuffer endpoint refused by name before emission | `OnResourceCopyRegion` rebuilds two `CopyImageEndpoint`s through the barrier-pulled `GetTextureObject(name)` and calls `GL.CopyImageSubData(...)` | 30 → 0; 6 `CopyImageLayeredScenario` lane entries | | `ShaderStorageBlockBinding` (4) | `set_storage_block_binding` (75), `kHasBlob` | `EmitShaderStorageBlockBinding`: `GlName`, `Binding`, `ShaderCso`, the block name staged `strlen + 1` | `OnSetStorageBlockBinding` → `GL.ShaderStorageBlockBinding(GlName, name, Binding)` | 4 → 0; the 2 `ProgramPipelineScenario` storage-block lane entries | Beside them, the two edits the contract names: - **`FieldOwnership.def`, the one row §6.9 grants i1**: `GetProgramForDispatch` FATAL → `BARRIER_PULLED, "P7 (Magma), P8 (Espryt)"`. Without it every migrated dispatch aborts on the backend's own `PrepareForCompute` (`DirectGLES.cpp:5779`, `VulkanRenderer.cpp:7327`). The FATAL block is two rows now, not three; tables regenerated with `gen_pipe_field_ownership.py`. - **`DirectGLES.cpp`, i1's one backend edit** (§2 i1, ruling §6.7): the `copy-image-shadow-mirror` site returns early under a non-monolith transport, behind `#if MOBILEGL_BUILD_DISAGGREGATED` so the pull build's code does not move (G1 `.text +0`), and armed on the TRANSPORT and not the build so build-split's monolith lanes still mirror. The pre-existing `#if MOBILEGL_PIPE_PUSH` `MGPipeUnmigratedEmulation` call is left where it was, so a push-only build is byte-for-byte unchanged. Tests: `RemoteEmitTable.TheSevenI1SlotsAreClassBAndAreNotTheFatalThunk`, `RemoteEmitTable.EachI1SlotReachesRequireSessionUnderItsOwnName` (five death tests, each asserting `Fatal{NoClientSession, ""}` and the ABSENCE of `Fatal{UnmigratedVerb`), `FieldOwnershipTest.TheComputeProgramIsServedUnderADispatchStampFromP5bOn`, the retargeted `FieldOwnershipTest.AFatalClassReadAbortsEvenWithoutStrictErrors` (its old exemplar was the field i1 moved), and 24 `integration-split` entries. Every one ships its "red once by doing X" line. --- ## 2. Acceptance numbers All on `~/w7/p5b-i1 @ e352e9a6`, `GLIBC_TUNABLES=glibc.malloc.tcache_count=0`. Logs `~/w7/p5b-i1-*.log`; census `~/w7/p5b-i1-census-logs/results.json`. ### 2.1 Builds — four for four `build-linux` (pull), `build-push`, `build-verify`, `build-split`: configure rc=0, build rc=0, `CTestTestfile.cmake` confirmed in each. ### 2.2 G1 — did not move ``` nm --defined-only build-linux/libMobileGL.so | grep -ic MG_Remote -> 0 symbol-report vs ~/w7/p5-before-libMobileGL.so, --threshold 0: .text 10806611 -> 10806611 (+0, +0.000%) 27814 -> 27814 defined symbols: 0 added, 0 removed, 0 resized, 0 renamed ``` Everything i1 adds is either inside `MG_Remote` (compiled only under `MOBILEGL_BUILD_DISAGGREGATED`), a `.def` row whose generated table the pull build never odr-uses, or the one backend site behind `#if MOBILEGL_BUILD_DISAGGREGATED`. ### 2.3 Generators and purity `gen_pipe.py --check` / `--self-test` (9 trips), `gen_pipe_field_ownership.py --check` / `--self-test` (15 trips, 63 fields, 7 sticky forwards, 9 refusals), `gen_pipe_dirty_surface.py --check`, `check_include_closure.py` (4 probes, 0 problems): all green. ### 2.4 Test lanes | lane | c0b baseline | i1 | |---|---|---| | `ctest -L unit` build-linux / push / verify | 1817 / 1817 each | **1817 / 1817** each, unchanged | | `ctest -L unit` build-split | 2084 / 2084 | **2089 / 2089** (+3 i1 cases, +2 from the x2m merge) | | `ctest -L integration-split` build-split, inproc | 22 / 22 | **46 / 46** (+24 i1 lane entries) | | `ctest -L integration-gpu` build-push, monolith | 1128 / 1128 | **1128 / 1128** | | G2 pull-vs-push `ctest -N`, every label | 0 diff | **0 diff** | | G14 build-linux names vs `p5-before-ctest-names.txt` | 0 removed, 43 added | **0 removed, 43 added** — identical to c0b; i1 adds NOTHING to the pull build | | G5 `p3a_untouched_regions.sh ff2994d9 HEAD` | rc=0 | **rc=0** | | G5 `p4a_untouched_regions.sh ff2994d9 HEAD` | rc=0 | **rc=0** | ### 2.5 The inproc census `~/w7/p5b-c0b-census.sh ~/w7/p5b-i1 ~/w7/p5b-i1-census-logs`. The manifest GREW by 24 — i1's lane entries carry `integration-gpu` as well as `integration-split`, and the census enumerates that label — so the diff below is over the **1149 entries c0b's baseline and this run share**, and the 24 new ones are reported separately (all 24 passed). | status | c0b baseline (`f5676103`) | i1, common 1149 | i1, all 1173 | |---|---:|---:|---:| | passed | 432 | **503** | 527 | | skipped | 185 | **195** | 195 | | subprocess-aborted | 505 | **335** | 335 | | ordinary failed | 27 | **116** | 116 | **Every transition came out of `aborted`. There is not one regression:** ``` passed -> passed 432 aborted -> aborted 335 skipped -> skipped 185 failed -> failed 27 aborted -> failed 89 aborted -> passed 71 aborted -> skipped 10 ``` No entry that passed on c0b's head does anything else on this one, and no entry that failed fails differently. **The census was run twice, before and after the x2m merge, and the two runs are identical** — same totals, same transition matrix, same per-slot table. So nothing below is x2m's, and every number is attributable to i1. --- ## 3. The gate: my five slots, and where their 239 entries went **All five counts are zero, and so are both companions:** | slot | c0b | i1 | |---|---:|---:| | `BindImageTexture` | 138 | **0** | | `DispatchCompute` | 49 | **0** | | `CopyImageSubData` | 30 | **0** | | `MemoryBarrier` | 18 | **0** | | `ShaderStorageBlockBinding` | 4 | **0** | | `DispatchComputeIndirect`, `MemoryBarrierByRegion` | 0 | **0** | 239 entries, not the brief's 235 — the brief's number omits the four `ShaderStorageBlockBinding` entries. Where each went: | was | |---| | **`BindImageTexture` 138** → 30 passed · 10 skipped · 45 `Fatal{UnmigratedEmulation, "texture-remint-pull"}` · 53 wrong-answer failures (52 of them DirectVulkan) | | **`DispatchCompute` 49** → 23 passed · 1 `texture-remint-pull` · 25 wrong-answer failures (all DirectVulkan) | | **`CopyImageSubData` 30** → 16 passed · 9 wrong-answer failures · 3 `Fatal{UnmigratedVerb, "ClearBufferfv"}` (f1's) · 2 `Fatal{UnmigratedVerb, "CopyImageSubData+RENDERBUFFER"}` (i1's own named refusal) | | **`MemoryBarrier` 18** → 12 `Fatal{UnmigratedVerb, "DrawElementsBaseVertex"}` · 6 `Fatal{UnmigratedVerb, "DrawElements"}` (both d1's) | | **`ShaderStorageBlockBinding` 4** → 2 passed · 2 wrong-answer failures (DirectVulkan) | ### The next first blockers, by name 1. **`Fatal{UnmigratedEmulation, "texture-remint-pull"}` — 46 entries, all DirectGLES.** `Managers.cpp:5634`. Exactly the bounded loss contract §6.7 predicted for the mirror skip. By scenario: `ImageTargetKindScenario` 22, `NonCoreImageFormatScenario` 9, `ImageFormatQualifierScenario` 4, `FormatlessImageBakeScenario` 3, `ImageLoadStoreSsoScenario` 2, `LayeredTextureReadbackScenario` 2, and one each of `AdvertisedLimitsScenario`, `ImageSizeAfterRespecScenario`, `P4aFinalFixScenario`, `TextureParamsWithoutASamplerViewScenario`. 2. **d1's draw slots — 18 entries**, the whole of `GuiBatchScenario` on both backends: `DrawElementsBaseVertex` 12, `DrawElements` 6. `GuiBatchScenario` was `MemoryBarrier`'s only scenario, and it is now entirely d1's. 3. **f1's `ClearBufferfv` — 3 entries**, the three `CopyImagePacked16Scenario.RenderbufferLandsInArrayMipLevelIntact` variants. 4. **i1's own named refusal — 2 entries**: `{DirectGLES,DirectVulkan}.PackedWordReadbackScenario.ACopyThroughARenderbufferReachesAnRgb9E5Destination` reach `Fatal{UnmigratedVerb, "CopyImageSubData+RENDERBUFFER"}`. The refusal is MEASURED now, which is what §6.6 asked for. 5. **89 wrong-answer failures** — §4.2 and §4.3 below. 82 DirectVulkan, 7 DirectGLES. --- ## 4. Rulings I made, each with what would overturn it 1. **The handles are LOOKED UP, never minted.** `MGPImageBind::Res`, `MGPCopyRegion::Src/Dst`, `MGPStorageBlockBinding::ShaderCso` and `MGPGridInfo::IndirectBuffer` come from `MGPipeSlots().FindByLifetimeId(...)`, not `Acquire(...)`. Every one of these sinks dispatches on the GL NAME — that is what rule D carries it for — so the handle is for P7. `Acquire` would MINT a slot at a call site that emits no create record, handing the server an identity it has never seen; a null field is the true statement "no handle published yet". *Overturned by* P7 dispatching on `Res` instead of `GlName`, which needs the minting form plus an ordering guarantee this row does not have. 2. **Only the two dispatch slots carry a pre-verb hook.** b1's hooks describe "the work the record is about to start". A bind, a barrier, an image copy and a block rebinding start no shader and read no mapped buffer; the dispatch that later reads the image is the verb that carries both hooks. Running them on all seven would push the same maps several times per dispatch and inflate b1's per-row counters. *Overturned by* a measured workload whose coherent-map write is read by a copy or a barrier with no dispatch between. 3. **The renderbuffer endpoint is refused on BOTH sides of the wire.** The client refuses before emission (ID-57's shape, so the census greps it where the other client refusals are) and the sink refuses a record that names `GL_RENDERBUFFER` in either target. *Overturned by* a renderbuffer sticky forward or P7's handle keying. 4. **A copy whose GL name no longer resolves DECLINES, it does not Fatal.** `OnResourceCopyRegion` logs once and returns false — the monolith's own answer in its own words (`DirectGLES.cpp:9067`, "declining the copy"); the frontend validator is what keeps it unreachable and what reports the `INVALID_VALUE` the application is owed. *Overturned by* a measured entry that reaches it, which would mean a pull went stale under the barrier. 5. **The atomic-counter barrier lowering stays in the backend.** `OnMemoryBarrier` forwards `Bits` untouched. Espryt's "counter bit implies storage bit" is a statement about the driver (`DirectGLES.cpp:8837`); repeating it client-side would make the split arm and the monolith arm two different calls. *Overturned by* nothing in P5b. ### 4.2 The ruling I was asked to make, and the measurement that changes its JUSTIFICATION Contract §6.7 rules the mirror skipped under split and says **"what the skip loses is bounded by two Fatals"**. I implemented the skip. The bound is **half right, and I measured both halves**: - The `texture-remint-pull` half is real: 46 entries reach it, by name (§3.1). - **The `glGetTexImage` half does not hold, and the skip is not what breaks those entries anyway.** I ran the experiment: with the skip compiled out (`if (false && …)`, rebuilt, re-run) the five DirectGLES packed-readback entries — `CopyImagePacked16Scenario.{Array,Flat}…` ×2, `WidenedPacked16` ×2, `PackedWordReadbackScenario.ACopiedRgb9E5Word…` — **fail identically**. So i1's mirror skip costs the lane exactly the 46 named aborts and nothing else. - What actually breaks those five is `glGetTexImage` under split: `GetTexImage_State` (`GL_Texture.cpp:5331`) rejects with `GL_INVALID_OPERATION` and returns BEFORE `GetTexImage_Backend`, so the class-C `Fatal{UnmigratedVerb, "GetTexImage"}` never fires and the caller keeps its zero-filled buffer. The scenario reads the zeros as texels. **A class-C slot that silently answers nothing instead of refusing by name is the one shape ID-47 says a picture comparison cannot see**, and it is worth the integrator's attention independently of i1 — it is wave-3 / P9 territory. *What would overturn the skip itself:* nothing i1 measured. If the integrator wants the honest alternative anyway, it is one line — delete the `#if MOBILEGL_BUILD_DISAGGREGATED` early return and those 46 entries go back to aborting `Fatal{UnmigratedEmulation, "copy-image-shadow-mirror"}` by name instead of proceeding. That trades 46 named aborts for 46 entries that get further. ### 4.3 The 89 wrong-answer failures, and why i1 does not believe they are i1's **82 of 89 are DirectVulkan (Magma); 7 are DirectGLES (Espryt).** The load-bearing observation is that **the same scenarios pass on Espryt and fail on Magma from the same wire records** — `DoublePrecisionScenario` 7/7 pass on DirectGLES and 7/7 fail on DirectVulkan, and so do `AtomicCounterScenario`, `SsboArrayLengthScenario`, `UniformInitializerScenario` and `ProgramPipelineScenario`. The record is backend-agnostic; only the backend differs. The Magma shape is uniform: the compute dispatch runs, no server-side error is logged, and the SSBO the shader writes reads back all zeros (`DirectVulkan.DoublePrecisionScenario.ADoubleUniformKeepsItsDeclaredInitializer`: `values[0]` is 0, 2.5 expected). Magma registers a real `DispatchCompute` slot, so the sink is calling it; what is missing is inside `VulkanRenderer::DispatchCompute`'s own state resolution under split. **Magma's split compute/image path is the next round's package, and it is the single biggest item i1 hands on.** The 7 DirectGLES failures: 5 are the `glGetTexImage` shape of §4.2; the other two are `TextureParamsWithoutASamplerViewScenario.ACopyImageEndpointOnlyTexturesParamsReachTheDriver` (a white-box G9 case whose own message diagnoses it: "the record reached the server and the server has not pushed it" — Espryt defers texture-param application to the first sampler view, and a copy-image-only destination never gets one) and one `ResourceSubsystemOff.LargeArenaAdoptionScenario…` entry that the runner classes `failed` while its own output says `SKIPPED` ("runs only in its own lane") — a census-classifier artifact, not a product failure. --- ## 5. What I believe the brief or the contract got wrong or left open 1. **The brief says 235 lane entries; it is 239.** 138 + 49 + 30 + 18 + 4. The four `ShaderStorageBlockBinding` entries are missing from the brief's arithmetic. 2. **Contract §6.7's "bounded by two Fatals" does not hold for the `glGetTexImage` half** — §4.2, with the experiment that shows it and the site that causes it. 3. **The census manifest is not a fixed 1149.** It is `ctest -L integration-gpu` on the tree under test, and every package that adds a split lane entry (which also carries `integration-gpu`) grows it. The four packages will each grow it; the diff has to be taken over the intersection, and c0b's 432/185/505/27 is a baseline for the COMMON entries only. 4. **A `DirectGLES.Split.` lane entry must emit a record** (`ScenarioFixture.h:86`), so a whole-scenario `TEST_FILTER` cannot be used for a scenario that has pure state cases: `ProgramPipelineScenario` has nine of them and they are red for having nothing to say. i1's block filters to `*StorageBlock*`. A package adding lane entries also has to extend `Harness/SplitLogPaths.cmake.in`, or `SplitLogPaths.PrivateAndDistinct` fails for the whole lane — that file's loop is a hard-coded list of TEST_LIST variables and every package needs a line in it. 5. **`FieldOwnershipTest` runs only in the split unit lane.** The three other unit lanes stay at 1817 with an i1 case added to that file; worth knowing before someone expects 1818. --- ## 6. Debts, and what the next round starts on - **Magma's split compute/image path** (§4.3) — 82 entries. Biggest single item. - **`glGetTexImage` silently answers nothing under split** (§4.2) instead of raising its class-C Fatal. Wave 3 / P9 owns the slot; the SILENCE is the part that should not wait for it. - **`texture-remint-pull`** — 46 entries; ROADMAP P8's client-side mirror retires it. - **`GetProgramForDispatch` is now a counted pull** (`rsp`), retired by P7 (Magma) / P8 (Espryt) with `GetProgramForDraw`. - **`MGPGridInfo::Block*` stay 0** and `IndirectBuffer` travels unread — P7 Magma fills the first from the reflection archive if it needs it. - **`MemoryBarrier` has no green lane case of its own**: `GuiBatchScenario` is its only census scenario and it is d1's `DrawElements` now. `AtomicCounterScenario` covers the row in the lane; a first-class one has to wait for d1. - **i1's slots are zero, so the lane's remaining 335 aborts are d1's, t2's and f1's**, led by `BeginTransformFeedback` 95, `DrawElements` 62, `PatchParameteri` 43, `DrawElementsBaseVertex` 16, `MultiDrawElementsBaseVertex` 18, `ClearBufferiv` 12, `ClearBufferfv` 9.