The Minecraft-shaped driver benchmark could only be run from a desktop shell
against a desktop driver, which is the wrong machine: MobileGL exists to run on
mobile GPUs, and nothing said what its translation costs there. This puts the
same cases on an Android device, both in the plugin's POST screen and from a
shell, and adds the native-driver baseline they have to be read against.
The cases move into DriverBenchCases.inc so both harnesses run byte-identical
bodies - the desktop program resolving entry points from one EGL provider, and
DriverBenchJni.cpp calling MobileGL's frontend in-process. The JNI file binds
every gl*/egl* name to MG_Impl by macro rather than by linkage: this library
legitimately has the platform libEGL and libGLESv3 in its own lookup scope, and
a benchmark that quietly measured the device driver instead of the translation
layer would have looked like very good news.
Frames are now closed with a fence wait instead of glFinish. MobileGL implements
glFinish and glFlush as no-ops, so the old loop timed submit-plus-GPU on a native
driver and submit-only on a MobileGL backend, and the two numbers did not
describe the same work.
To measure a device's own driver the cases needed to be expressible in GLES:
ESSL 3.20 twins of the four shaders (chosen at runtime from GL_VERSION, since
MobileGL is deliberately still fed desktop GLSL - translating it is the thing
under test), a multi-draw hook that loops DrawElementsBaseVertex where the
multi-draw entry point does not exist, and an EGL bootstrap that falls back from
desktop GL to GLES 3. The binary cross-compiles for arm64 unchanged.
BenchService hosts each run in its own process and exits afterwards. That is not
caution: the backend is latched from MOBILEGL_BACKEND_TYPE at initialization, so
Espryt and Magma can never share a process, and Espryt's teardown terminates the
process-default EGL display, which would take the POST activity's own EGL
objects with it.
Running it found that Magma could not create a windowless context on Mali at
all - CreateInstance required VK_EXT_headless_surface, which no mobile driver
here exposes, and aborted the process. The Xlib path already probes and falls
back to a hidden window for the same reason on NVIDIA; Android now probes too
and hands the WSI an AImageReader's ANativeWindow, a real producer surface
attached to no display whose images are never acquired. DriverPost reports the
extension's absence as a WARN so the fallback is visible rather than silent.
Measured on a Mali-G77 MC9 (native / Espryt / Magma, ns per operation):
5495 chunk draws 14397 / 36934 / 33763, the 26.2 per-draw uniform-range pattern
13710 / 31205 / 21252, sodium-style multi-draw 256956 / 238389 / 209527. The
translation costs about 2.4x per draw here against 5-9x on the desktop, because
the mobile driver's own per-call cost dwarfs it - and both backends beat the
native driver on multi-draw, which it has to emulate.
Desktop unit tests 421/421; the POST screen and both Run Bench buttons verified
on the device.
Five independent bits of per-draw and per-operation waste in the DirectVulkan
backend, all removing work whose answer was already known.
The per-draw descriptor walk iterated all 256 slots of bindingKinds to find the
one to eight bindings a real GL program declares, because that vector is sized to
the binding cap rather than to the program. Reflection now records the bindings it
actually assigned, and the draw path iterates that. It is built at the end of
ReflectLayout, not where bindingKinds is sized - at that point the vector is only
zero-initialised and the kinds are assigned further down, so a list built there
would be empty. It has to stay ascending: Vulkan consumes pDynamicOffsets in
binding order and the writer pushes them in iteration order, so an unordered list
would silently mis-pair dynamic offsets with their uniform blocks.
Descriptor pools were sized maxSets * the 256-binding cap, declaring 81,920
descriptors per pool and 245,760 across the frames in flight, for sets that hold
what shader reflection found. Sized from eight now; an outlier program is absorbed
by the VK_ERROR_OUT_OF_POOL_MEMORY path that already exists, which works because
pool sizes are aggregate budgets rather than per-set limits.
TrackLiveResource swept the whole live-buffer vector on every insert once it
passed 256 entries, and when the buffers are all live the sweep removes nothing
and the vector grows by one - so creating N live buffers cost about N^2/2
expired() checks. It sweeps on a doubling watermark now, with the same
reclamation semantics.
GenerateMipmap transitioned each destination level individually inside its loop,
but every generated level starts in the same layout and the loop only moves a
level out of TRANSFER_DST after writing it, so the whole range can be prepared in
one barrier - 3(N-1)+1 barrier commands become 2(N-1)+2. Each level is still
transitioned to TRANSFER_SRC before it is read, so the dependency between
consecutive levels is unchanged.
WaitForFrameSerial drained the entire graphics queue, as its own comment admitted.
Every submission records the frame serial it was made under, so it now waits on
the first fence at or past the requested serial. The narrow path deliberately does
not call NotifyDeviceIdle(): that claims every submission has retired, which is
only true after a real drain, so it stays on the fallback.
Verified with an 8213-case A/B (textures, buffers, queries, mipmaps, uniforms and
the whole direct_state_access suite): the Espryt failure list is identical, the
Magma failure list differs by one case, and both crash sets are unchanged on
Magma. That one case, buffer_storage.map_persistent_draw, does not reproduce in
isolation - running the buffer_storage group alone gives byte-identical results on
both builds (the same three failures, not including it), and it reports
NotSupported when run on its own. It is the same ordering-dependent behaviour this
suite shows elsewhere, and the three Espryt crash-set differences are the known
copy_image cluster moving chunk position. Flagging rather than hiding it.
direct_state_access stays at Espryt 370/371 and Magma 371/371; unit tests 421/421.
RenderState kept one version counter for all render state, and DirectVulkan read
it in three places: the pipeline memo key, the SetupDrawSnapshot fast-path guard,
and that guard's store. So glViewport, glScissor, glBlendColor, glStencilMask,
glClearColor, glPolygonOffset, glLineWidth and the point-size family - none of
which can alter a VkPipeline, all of which an application changes between draws -
knocked the next draw off both fast paths and made it rebuild a pipeline lookup
that was already correct.
The counter is now split. m_version still moves on every state change, because
the draw snapshot really does depend on all of it. m_pipelineStateVersion moves
only for the state a backend bakes into a pipeline object, and it is what the
three DirectVulkan sites read.
The exclusion list is the eight VkDynamicState entries PipelineFactory declares
plus the state that is not pipeline state at all (the clear values, hints, the
point-size family, clamp read colour, the primitive restart index). glStencilFunc
is the one setter that had to be split rather than classified: Func is in the
pipeline payload but Ref and ValueMask are dynamic state, so it bumps the
pipeline version only when Func actually changes.
Capabilities are deliberately NOT in the exclusion list even though several look
like dynamic state: GL_FRAMEBUFFER_SRGB feeds the render-pass hash, depth and
stencil test feed drawUsesDepthStencil, and scissor test, blend, cull face,
polygon offset fill, primitive restart, colour logic op and rasterizer discard
all feed the pipeline payload.
Two smaller draw-path wins ride along, both removing work whose answer was
already in hand. UploadAndBindVertexStreams searched all 32 VAO attribute slots
for the SharedPtr matching a binding's buffer key, once per binding per draw -
but VertexInputStateFactory writes bindingBufferKeys[b] and
bindingAttributeLocations[b] from the same loop iteration, one binding per
attribute with no merging, so the attribute at that location IS the buffer, by
construction. UploadAndBindIndexBuffer round-tripped the element-array buffer's
raw pointer back through the GL name table on every indexed draw, costing a map
lookup and an atomic refcount pair, when the binding slot's SharedPtr was already
in scope forty lines above - where a comment says exactly that about the vertex
path.
Behaviour-neutral by construction and verified as such: a 13355-case subset of
GL30-GL45 covering viewport, scissor, blend, stencil, depth, polygon offset,
clear, multisample, cull, logic op, line width and point state, plus the whole
direct_state_access suite, is identical before and after on both backends - in
the failure list and in the crashed-case set. direct_state_access stays at
Espryt 370/371 and Magma 371/371.
Whether a backend can attach a single layer of a texture to a framebuffer was one
Bool, so it could only give the most conservative answer any target needed.
DirectVulkan therefore declined every layer of every target and
direct_state_access.framebuffers_texture_layer_attachment failed with 542
messages across four targets.
The three ways a GL layer maps onto Vulkan are independent capabilities, so the
flag becomes a per-TextureTarget mask. A 2D or 2D multisample array layer IS a
VkImage array layer and needed nothing but the gate opened. A cube map array is
one 2D image with arrayLayers = 6 * cubeCount and CUBE_COMPATIBLE, which is a
shape VkTextureManager simply did not have - it is declined softly when the depth
is not a whole number of cubes or the level is not square, because that function's
Bool return exists for unrepresentable shapes and asserting there would abort on
ordinary input, GL_PROXY_TEXTURE_CUBE_MAP_ARRAY above all. A 3D texture's layer is
a z slice, which needs a 2D-array-compatible image and a per-slice clear, because
vkCmdClearColorImage cannot address a subset of a 3D image's slices - a render
pass whose only content is its LOAD_OP_CLEAR can, since its attachment is a 2D
view over that one slice.
VK_IMAGE_CREATE_2D_ARRAY_COMPATIBLE_BIT is asked for per format and withdrawn per
format, mirroring the MUTABLE_FORMAT pattern already in this file: the capability
is per format+usage, so a single global probe answers a different question than
the one the frontend goes on to ask. Losing it costs per-slice attachment for that
format; failing creation would lose the texture.
Three things found on the way that are not the headline:
glFramebufferTextureLayer, the non-DSA twin, had no gate at all and additionally
refused cube map arrays that GL 4.5 requires it to accept. GL 4.6 core 9.2.8 makes
the two entry points equivalent, so they now decline in the same places - leaving
one ungated is what let an unrepresentable attachment reach the renderer.
ComputeFullMipLevelCount takes max(x, y, z), and for every array shape z is the
layer count rather than a mip-able axis, so a 4x4 array with 192 layers asked for
six mip levels on an image whose legal maximum is three
(VUID-VkImageCreateInfo-mipLevels-00958). Only the image's own extent can bound
it. lavapipe had been letting that through.
A layered GL clear queues layerCount = depth, which is illegal for a
VK_IMAGE_TYPE_3D image (VUID-vkCmdClearColorImage-baseArrayLayer-01472 pins it to
0/1, read as the whole mip level) and the old code passed it straight through.
Takes framebuffers_texture_layer_attachment green on DirectVulkan, so the whole
direct_state_access suite is 371/371 there; Espryt stays 370/371, the remaining
case being the fp64 one it declines by design.
Known and deliberately not fixed here, with a FIXME at the site:
KHR-GL44/45/46.geometry_shader.layered_framebuffer.clear_call_support now fails on
DirectVulkan - a layered clear of a 3D texture reads back zeros. Those cases exist
only in the GL44+ lists, above the 4.0 this backend reports. An A/B of a 6935-case
subset (cube map array, texture storage, framebuffer, 3D, the full DSA suite and
the GL33 texture group) is otherwise clean on both backends: 16 cases fixed and
none broken on Espryt, 15 fixed and those 2 broken on Magma, and zero difference
anywhere at GL 4.0 or below. The FIXME records which causes were already ruled out
by bisection so the next reader does not repeat them.
Vulkan's built-in convention is "provoking vertex first"; GL's default is
LAST_VERTEX_CONVENTION, and GL derives both flat shading and the transform
feedback vertex order from it. DirectVulkan had no way to say so, which is why
direct_state_access.queries_functional failed on a value with nothing in its log
- the primitives came back counted against a strip recorded in the wrong vertex
order.
VK_EXT_provoking_vertex is now enabled when present, and the mode is a hashed
field of the pipeline payload rather than dynamic state, because it is baked into
VkPipelineRasterizationStateCreateInfo: two draws differing only in it must not
collide on one cached VkPipeline, or whichever mode built first would stick for
the rest of the frame. The pNext is chained only when the mode is not Vulkan's
default, so a device without the extension produces a byte-identical
VkGraphicsPipelineCreateInfo to before.
Two carve-outs, both measured rather than reasoned:
A geometry shader already emits its triangles in GL's vertex order, so asking for
LAST rotates them a second time and transform_feedback.geometry reads back the
wrong vertices. The mode is one pipeline bit and the input-assembler path wants
the opposite, so the two cannot both be satisfied: a program that runs a geometry
shader and captures transform feedback keeps Vulkan's own convention. That test
is read off the program's own shader list, not
programObj.rasterizationProducerStage - the latter is filled by the clip-fixup
analysis, which does not run for every program and reads Unknown for exactly the
programs this guard exists to catch. Both halves are link-time facts folded into
programObj.hash, so no pipeline memo can hand back one built for the other mode;
keying on IsTransformFeedbackActive() instead would be a live bug, since neither
memo key moves on glBeginTransformFeedback.
transformFeedbackPreservesProvokingVertex is deliberately not requested. It buys
nothing here - the capture order queries_functional needs comes from
provokingVertexLast alone - and leaving it off keeps
VUID-VkGraphicsPipelineCreateInfo-topology-04884 disarmed, so a TRIANGLE_FAN
pipeline may take LAST on any device.
The blit pipeline routes through the same selector: it has no flat varying and no
capture, but on a device without provokingVertexModePerPipeline a blit left on
FIRST inside a render pass whose draws are LAST is an illegal mix.
Per the POST rule the new extension gets rows for provokingVertexLast and for the
two properties that change what MobileGL can promise.
Fixes queries_functional on Magma (370/371). An A/B over a 976-case transform
feedback / geometry shader / layered rendering subset of GL30-GL45 is otherwise
identical on both backends and additionally takes 14 geometry_shader rendering
and layered_rendering cases from failing to passing on Magma.
glVertexAttribLFormat validated its arguments and then refused unconditionally
with "64-bit vertex attributes are not supported", so
direct_state_access.vertex_arrays_attribute_format failed every GL_DOUBLE
subcase on both backends - the format never landed, the draw fetched whatever
the attribute held before, and the captured values came back as reinterpreted
garbage.
The attribute is now real state. IsLong is its own bit rather than being
inferred from Float64, because glVertexAttribFormat(GL_DOUBLE) also reads
doubles - it just asks for them converted to float - so the type alone cannot
tell the two apart. It participates in the format comparison, so an L-format
call over a plain one still bumps the version, and glVertexAttribPointer clears
it inside the mutation block so the clear and the bump stay atomic.
GL_VERTEX_ATTRIB_ARRAY_LONG stops being hardcoded false, and the pname is now
accepted by the attribute queries at all.
Support is detected, never assumed. SupportsFloat64VertexAttributes comes from
VkPhysicalDeviceFeatures::shaderFloat64 on DirectVulkan and is false on
DirectGLES - not a driver question there and never will be, since ES has no
GL_DOUBLE vertex format and ESSL has no fp64 type to consume one with. A backend
without it declines in the entry point, with the GL error and a log line naming
the reason, rather than accepting state no draw could honour. Both cases get a
DriverPost row so the loss is named at startup instead of at draw setup.
On DirectVulkan the attribute deliberately does not use VK_FORMAT_R64*_SFLOAT:
those are optional and lavapipe advertises zero features for all four of them.
It is fetched as its 32-bit word pair (R32G32_UINT / R32G32B32A32_UINT) and
bitcast back to double in the shader by a new SPIR-V pass, which is bit-exact
and needs no format capability at all. The pass re-declares the input as uvec2 /
uvec4, demotes the original variable to a Private global and seeds it once at
the top of the entry point, so every existing load keeps its id and its double
type and no other instruction is rewritten. Both halves branch on nothing but
"is this attribute long", so they cannot disagree - and if the pass ever fails,
the assertion fires rather than letting a UINT format sit under a double input.
The pointer types are all created before any variable that names them and the
demoted variable is moved after them, since the types-and-variables section may
not forward-reference a type.
dvec3/dvec4 are declined rather than fetched wrong: six or eight uint32
components have no single VkFormat, and GL spreads such an input over two
attribute locations, which the location-per-index model here does not express.
Fixes vertex_arrays_attribute_format on Magma (369/371). On Espryt it stays
failing, now as a detected and explained decline rather than a blanket refusal.
The pipeline object bookkeeping landed already - names, stage slots, queries -
but nothing consumed it. Every draw asked the context for the current program,
got null because a pipeline is used with program zero, and drew nothing;
glCreateShaderProgramv was still a stub returning zero, so
direct_state_access.program_pipelines_functional could not even build its stage
programs and reported InternalError on both backends.
glCreateShaderProgramv is written as the exact call sequence the spec defines it
to be, with one deviation that matters: the link goes straight to
ProgramObject::Link(false) rather than through LinkProgram, because LinkProgram
injects a default fragment shader into a program that has none - correct for a
whole program, wrong for a separable vertex-stage one whose fragment stage comes
from the pipeline. glDetachShader defers removal to the next link, so the program
keeps the shader object it was built from while correctly no longer reporting it
attached. GL_PROGRAM_SEPARABLE joins glProgramParameteri and glGetProgramiv.
Everything downstream of a draw - both backends, the uniform plumbing, the draw
validation - is written against one linked program, so rather than teach all of
it about stages, the pipeline is flattened: GetProgramForDraw() composites the
stage programs' shaders into a single hidden program object and caches it against
a signature of each stage program's lifetime id and link generation, so it is
rebuilt exactly when a stage or a stage's link changes. The composite carries no
GL name - it must not answer glIsProgram, and it must not consume a name the
application could be handed.
Uniform entry points get their own resolver rather than sharing that one:
glUniform* addresses the pipeline's active program, not the composited draw
program. GL_CURRENT_PROGRAM still reads the program in use, which is zero here.
Fixes program_pipelines_functional on both backends.
Three DirectVulkan gaps found together.
glBlitFramebuffer's depth/stencil path refused any blit whose source and
destination extents differ, because vkCmdCopyImage cannot resize. vkCmdBlitImage
can, and VK_FILTER_NEAREST is the only filter Vulkan allows for depth/stencil
anyway - which is what the GL front end already requires. A same-size pair keeps
the cheaper copy.
Worse, that refusal and four others were `return`, not `continue`, so a
depth/stencil aspect this backend could not handle abandoned the whole function -
including the colour blit that only starts after the aspect loop. The CTS's
scaling blits therefore lost their colour as well, which is why
direct_state_access.framebuffers_blit failed all three of its checks rather than
one.
VulkanRenderer::GenerateMipmap declined GL_TEXTURE_1D. It needed nothing else:
the blit loop derives every offset from the storage extent, and a 1D texture's is
{width, 1, 1}, which is exactly the y and z offsets a 1D image requires.
Also: IsTimerQueryResultReady now asks the query pool before the frame serial.
The pool polls with VK_QUERY_RESULT_WITH_AVAILABILITY_BIT and is the authority;
the frame serial only advances at Present and neither completion notifier will
mark the current serial done, so a timestamp written and fence-waited inside one
GL frame could never be read back within it.
Takes framebuffers_blit and textures_generate_mipmaps from failing to passing on
DirectVulkan. queries_functional still fails there on a value.
ResolveAttachmentBaseArrayLayer answered zero for everything but a cube map face,
so every blit, copy and glReadPixels against a layered attachment read layer zero
whatever was attached. It reads the attachment's layer now.
A 3D texture needs the other half of the distinction: its image has arrayLayers
== 1 and the GL layer is a z slice, which VkBufferImageCopy will not take as a
base array layer. BlitImageBinding carries it separately as depthOffset, and the
readback copy region uses it as the image offset's z.
Takes textures_copy from failing to passing on DirectVulkan, which is what
glCopyTextureSubImage3D needs to see the slice the CTS attached rather than
slice zero.
Two reasons a framebuffer's contents came back wrong, both on the read/clear
side rather than the write side.
Stencil, on both backends. The CTS reads stencil with glReadPixels(GL_STENCIL_INDEX,
GL_INT), which is as legal as the unsigned widths, and neither backend accepted
it: DirectGLES's ReadPixelsStencilViaNative rejected every signed type, after
which the call fell through to a native ES read the driver refuses and nothing
was written at all, so the caller kept its zeros; DirectVulkan's pack switch had
no GL_INT case, and of the cases it did have only GL_UNSIGNED_INT sourced the
stencil plane - GL_FLOAT and GL_UNSIGNED_SHORT emitted a depth value, which is
meaningless for a stencil-only image. Both now take the signed and float widths,
and DirectVulkan decides "this is a stencil read" once rather than per type.
DirectGLES also gains the GL_FLOAT_32_UNSIGNED_INT_24_8_REV fallback a
DEPTH32F_STENCIL8 attachment needs, which rejects the 24_8 packed type.
sRGB, on DirectVulkan. Every other write path goes through the UNORM twin view
while GL_FRAMEBUFFER_SRGB is off, storing the raw value GL asked for, but a
deferred clear is materialised with vkCmdClearColorImage - which names the image,
so the driver applied the sRGB transfer function and a clear to 0.25 landed at
0.537. PreCompensateSrgbClearColor hands it the linear colour whose encoding is
the requested value instead. It is a no-op for non-sRGB destinations, for integer
clear encodings, and when GL_FRAMEBUFFER_SRGB is on and GL really does want the
encode.
Takes renderbuffers_storage from failing to passing on both backends, plus
renderbuffers_storage_multisample and framebuffers_blit on Espryt.
Both direct_state_access.textures_generate_mipmap* cases crashed DirectVulkan.
Two causes, neither of them a broken invariant:
glGenerateMipmap and glGenerateTextureMipmap never checked cube completeness, so
an incomplete cube map went straight to the backend, which asserts that the
texture it is handed is complete. GL 4.6 core 8.14.4 makes that call
INVALID_OPERATION - there is no consistent set of faces to filter down - and both
entry points now say so through a shared check.
VulkanRenderer::GenerateMipmap asserted that the target was one of the four it
implements. 1D, 1D array and cube map array are legal GL and the front end passes
them through, so meeting one is a gap in this backend's coverage; it now logs and
declines, leaving the generated levels unwritten rather than aborting.
textures_generate_mipmap_errors passes on both backends now. textures_generate_mipmaps
stops crashing but still fails: DirectVulkan does not generate the 1D mip chain
the case checks - the frontend's storage allocation gives the levels the right
sizes, which is why the case passes when run on its own, but not the descending
content the full-run state leaves it looking for.
glClearBufferiv and glClearBufferuiv flattened their values into the payload's float vector,
and every clear was later written into VkClearColorValue::float32. Vulkan reads that union
according to the destination image's format rather than converting between its members, so
an R8I attachment cleared to -16 received the bit pattern of -16.0f. On top of that,
QueueRenderbufferClear copied only the float vector into the pending clear, so even the
flattened value was dropped and the attachment kept reading zero - which is what the
conformance tests actually observed.
The payload now records which of the three entry points supplied the colour and keeps the
value in that form, and one helper builds the union member the encoding calls for. GL's rule
that a format with no alpha channel reads as one has to be applied in the value's own type,
so the "does this format lack alpha" question is now asked separately from the substitution
and the helper applies it to whichever member is live. glClear is left on the float path
explicitly: ClearFramebufferPayload has no other form.
Takes every integer renderbuffer format in direct_state_access.renderbuffers_storage from
failing to passing on Magma - 115 reported mismatches down to 20, the rest being the stencil
formats Espryt fails too and SRGB8_ALPHA8 - and makes framebuffers_clear pass on both
backends.
glClearNamedFramebufferiv and glClearNamedFramebufferuiv were stubs, so a clear through
them was silently dropped and the attachment kept whatever it held. Their float siblings
were already implemented, which is what made the gap look like a rendering bug rather than
a missing entry point.
Which buffers they accept is narrower than glClearNamedFramebufferfv and differs between
the two: signed values clear COLOR or STENCIL, unsigned only COLOR (GL 4.6 core 17.4.3.1).
Only the colour buffer is indexed, so a stencil clear naming any drawbuffer other than 0 is
INVALID_VALUE rather than merely ignored, and anything else is INVALID_ENUM. Resolving the
framebuffer by name goes through the same helper the float forms use, which is what reports
INVALID_OPERATION for a name that is neither zero nor an existing framebuffer.
Both backends express them the way they already express the float forms: DirectGLES binds
the named framebuffer and forwards to glClearBuffer*, Magma queues the payload against the
named framebuffer rather than the bound one.
direct_state_access.framebuffers_clear_errors passes on both backends, and
framebuffers_clear passes on Espryt. Magma still fails that one, for a separate reason on
the materialization side rather than in these entry points.
The backend already turned a tessellation control/evaluation shader into the
right VkShaderStage, but nothing downstream knew what to do with it: GL_PATCHES
had no topology, so it fell through to the triangle-list default, and the
pipeline carried no tessellation state at all. A GL_PATCHES draw therefore ran
the vertex and fragment stages over raw triangles.
Map GL_PATCHES to VK_PRIMITIVE_TOPOLOGY_PATCH_LIST, carry GL_PATCH_VERTICES into
the pipeline as patchControlPoints (part of the key, since two patch sizes are
two pipelines), attach VkPipelineTessellationStateCreateInfo for a patch topology
only, and enable the tessellationShader device feature.
POST reports the feature, because without it a program with a tessellation stage
cannot build a pipeline at all and GL_PATCHES draws render nothing.
Vulkan restarts only on the fixed all-ones value of the index type, so
GL_PRIMITIVE_RESTART with a glPrimitiveRestartIndex of anything else used to
hard-fail the draw. GL_PRIMITIVE_RESTART_FIXED_INDEX already matches Vulkan and
is untouched.
Rewrite the indices into a transient copy instead, substituting the fixed value
for the application's. An index that already equals the fixed value would then be
indistinguishable from a restart, so it is nudged down by one: it can only be a
real index, since the application's restart index is a different number, and the
vertex it names is outside any well-defined draw -- whereas leaving it alone would
tear the primitive in two.
The element array buffer is rewritten whole rather than only the drawn range,
because an indirect draw's firstIndex lives in GPU memory and cannot be adjusted
from here; every element therefore keeps its position.
A capture is a GPU write like any shader's, so a later CPU read of the buffer has
to wait for it. Only shader storage buffers were flagged, so mapping or reading
back a capture buffer could observe whatever the queue had retired so far.
Nothing needs copying -- the capture writes land in coherent host-visible storage
already -- but coherence only says the writes are visible once they have
happened, which is exactly what MarkGpuWritten arranges through the readback op.
GL makes transform feedback results visible to every later command on their own,
with no glMemoryBarrier in between -- unlike shader storage writes. An
application replaying a capture with glDrawTransformFeedback is therefore
entitled to the captured bytes without asking for them, so the barrier the Vulkan
memory model requires has to come from here.
It cannot be recorded where the write happens: the capturing draw runs inside a
render pass that declares no self-dependency. Flag it there instead and emit the
barrier at the next point that could read the buffer -- the following draw's
setup, or a readback -- ending the render pass first, the same shape
glMemoryBarrier already uses.
The destination covers every way a captured buffer comes back: replayed as vertex
attributes or indices, read through a uniform or storage binding, sourced as an
indirect command, copied out, or mapped.
Vulkan's VK_VERTEX_INPUT_RATE_INSTANCE advances an attribute once per instance and has
no way to say anything else, so every non-zero divisor collapsed to 1: an attribute the
application asked to change every three instances changed every one, and
KHR-GL40.draw_indirect.basic-drawArrays-instancing and its elements sibling drew the
wrong colours from instance one onward.
VK_EXT_vertex_attribute_divisor is exactly this state, so it is enabled when the device
has it and the per-binding divisors ride into the pipeline through
VkPipelineVertexInputDivisorStateCreateInfoEXT. Only divisors other than 1 are listed -
1 is what the plain input rate already means - and they join the layout hash, so two
layouts that differ only in a divisor no longer share a pipeline.
POST reports the feature either way, because without it the failure is silent and looks
like a shader bug: the attribute is fetched, just from the wrong instance. The GLES side
gains the two checks this session's other work made load-bearing for the same reason -
glPatchParameteri (without it GL_PATCH_VERTICES stays at the driver's 3 and a patch draw
of any other size renders nothing) and the transform feedback object entry points
(without them a second object cannot open a capture while the first is paused).
KHR-GL40.draw_indirect on Magma: 70/70 but for the arbitrary primitive-restart index,
which Vulkan cannot express at all.
Texture uploads go out on a command buffer of their own the moment they happen, while
glGenerateMipmap records its blit chain into the frame's command buffer, which is not
submitted until the frame ends. So a glTexSubImage2D into a level that was just
generated reached the GPU FIRST and the blits then wrote over it.
KHR-GL40.texture_gather.base-level does exactly that - generates the chain, then writes
the texels it is going to sample into level 1 and points TEXTURE_BASE_LEVEL at it - and
read back the generated content instead of what it had written. The image view, the mip
range and the upload itself were all correct; only their order on the GPU was not.
This is the same hazard the mip-chain-growth recreate above already flushes for, from
the other side: there the recorded work had to reach the GPU before an out-of-band copy
read the image, here before an out-of-band copy writes it. Submitting at the end of the
generation orders every upload that can follow.
Reading a buffer a compute shader wrote gave zeros: the frontend shadow that MapBuffer
resolves against is only maintained by uploads, and Magma had no path back. Every
KHR-GL40.texture_gather case ends by dispatching a compute shader into an SSBO and
comparing the mapped result, so 66 of 75 failed on it.
Magma needs no readback: EnsureGpuResidentStorage - the same host-visible coherent
adoption the transform feedback capture already uses - makes the shadow BE the memory
the shader writes, so binding a buffer as a shader storage buffer now adopts it. What
coherence does not give is ordering: the writes are visible once they have happened,
and the CPU was reading before the dispatch had retired. The readback op therefore
submits the recorded work and waits.
That exposed a mistake in the frontend flag this rides on: MarkGpuWritten skipped
GPU-resident buffers, reasoning there was no shadow to refresh. True, but the wait is
still needed - "reconcile with the GPU write" is not always "copy it back", and which
of the two it is belongs to the backend. The flag now only says a write is outstanding;
DirectGLES's readback still skips its persistent-mapped buffers when copying.
KHR-GL40.texture_gather on Magma: 66 failures -> 19 (the rest are rectangle textures,
mipmap completeness and tessellation, all still to do). Espryt stays at 75/75.
The indirect draw paths bounded their read out of GL_DRAW_INDIRECT_BUFFER - and took
their default stride - from `sizeof(DrawCmdParam)`, this renderer's own draw-parameter
struct. That is not the command GL defines: DrawCmdParam carries two extra members for
bounding vertex-stream conversion and is 24 bytes, where GL's DrawArraysIndirectCommand
is four uint32.
So every glDrawArraysIndirect against a tightly-sized indirect buffer - which is what an
application writes, and what the CTS writes - failed the range check and drew nothing.
It went unnoticed on the elements side only by coincidence: DrawIndexedCmdParam happens
to be exactly the 20 bytes of DrawElementsIndirectCommand.
Both sizes are now named constants of GL's own layout.
KHR-GL40.draw_indirect on Magma: 21 failures -> 3.
The frontend half of ARB_transform_feedback2 landed for both backends, but Magma's
capture was still written for the one implicit span GL 3.3 has:
- A paused span kept capturing. VK_EXT_transform_feedback's counter buffers already
make consecutive draws append, so pausing is simply "do not wrap this draw" - the
counters keep their values and the next resumed draw carries on where the last
captured one stopped.
- Those counter buffers were context-wide. Transform feedback objects can each hold an
open, paused span at the same time - KHR-GL40.transform_feedback.draw_xfb_test keeps
three - and they were all appending through one set of four slots. Each object now
gets its own group, handed out on first use; past sixteen objects they share group 0,
which only matters for concurrently-paused spans.
- The generation that identifies a span is what a backend keys its append state on, so
it is now part of the per-object state the frontend saves and restores. Without that,
resuming an object that was paused before another one began looked like a new span
and restarted its counters at zero.
GL_PRIMITIVES_GENERATED needed one more thing. It counts what the last vertex
processing stage emitted whether or not anything is being captured, but
VK_QUERY_TYPE_TRANSFORM_FEEDBACK_STREAM_EXT only counts what the capture saw - so a
draw made while the span was paused is invisible to it. The frontend now tallies those
draws, and the Vulkan query adds the delta at result time. The correction lives in the
backend that needs it: an ES driver's GL_PRIMITIVES_GENERATED counts them by itself, and
adding it there too would double them.
transform_feedback* on Magma: 4 failures -> 3. Espryt stays at 38/38.
Sizing backings by their defined mip level count gave every level-0-only texture a
single-level image, and left growing it to the recreate-and-preserve path: the new
image is created and the old contents are carried over by a vkCmdCopyImage that
PreserveTextureContentsOnRecreate submits on its own command buffer and waits on
straight away.
Whatever the frame has already recorded into the old image has not been submitted
yet at that point, so that copy reads the texture as it stood before this frame's
writes. GenerateMipmap then descends the whole chain from a stale level 0, and the
composite pass that samples it renders a washed-out frame -
minecraft-1.21.4-fabric-iris-iterationt-in-world (Iris's mipmapped colour target,
the one texture in the trace that grows 1 -> 10 levels) came back at ssim 0.5699
against a 0.99 threshold.
This is the hazard the storage-usage upgrade already flushes for before its own
preserve-copy; growing the mip chain is simply the second trigger of that same
recreate, and it was added without the same ordering guarantee. Flush there too,
gated on a texture whose live image really does carry a short chain, so the submit
happens once per texture and only when a recreate is actually coming.
Keeps the single-level backing and its memory saving; ssim goes back to 0.9992.
ResolveColorBlitBinding cached a RenderbufferResource*/TextureResource*
(trackedLayout) before the pending-clear materialization step ran. For an
attachment that had never been part of any render pass yet (e.g. a
GL_NONE draw buffer slot read back via an explicit glReadBuffer), the
materialize call was the first thing to touch its resource, and creating
that entry in the UnorderedMap (FastSTL, open-addressing) can rehash and
invalidate every previously-taken pointer into the map - including the
one just cached. The read then saw a stale VK_IMAGE_LAYOUT_UNDEFINED and
silently bailed (via a compiled-out MGLOG_E in release builds), leaving
the client buffer untouched. Reordering so the clear is materialized
first, then the binding resolved, guarantees the pointer reflects the
final resource state. Fixes KHR-GL3{0,1,2,3}.draw_buffers.draw_buffers_1.
Real drivers (NVIDIA proprietary Linux) don't implement VK_EXT_headless_surface,
which the pbuffer path required unconditionally, hard-aborting at CreateInstance.
CreateInstance now detects instance-extension support and requests
VK_KHR_xlib_surface instead when headless is unavailable; CreateSurface creates
an unmapped Xlib window purely to obtain a VkSurfaceKHR, then proceeds through
the existing swapchain path unchanged. Shutdown destroys the window it owns.
Lavapipe and other headless-capable ICDs are unaffected.
Color blits from a multisampled source now use vkCmdResolveImage (both
blit resolvers carry the image sample count); a buffer named in the blit
mask but absent from either framebuffer skips just that buffer instead
of cancelling the whole blit (GL 4.6 18.3.1); and three-channel color
renderbuffers widen to their RGBA twin exactly like textures, so
renderbuffer<->texture blits of the same GL format see one VkFormat.
framebuffer_blit.multisampled_to_singlesampled_blit_color_config_test
passes - the whole framebuffer_blit family is green.
BlitFramebuffer now serves any GL_COLOR/DEPTH/STENCIL mask combination:
the depth/stencil aspects run as per-aspect image copies before the color
path, renderbuffer attachments materialize their pending clears like
texture ones, and the scissor test clips blit writes (destination rect
intersected, source shrunk proportionally). Depth copies between images
of different depth formats (a D24S8 renderbuffer into a
DEPTH_COMPONENT24 texture riding the D32_SFLOAT fallback) round-trip
through the host with a per-texel re-encode; stencil aspects pass
through raw since every packed format encodes S8. scissor_blit and
packed_depth_stencil.blit.* now pass.
The TF primitive queries now ride VK_QUERY_TYPE_TRANSFORM_FEEDBACK_STREAM_EXT
pools when the device reports transformFeedbackQueries: each captured draw
is wrapped in a slot (shared between both GL targets when active
together), and results sum the (written, needed) pairs -
GL_TRANSFORM_FEEDBACK_PRIMITIVES_WRITTEN from the first,
GL_PRIMITIVES_GENERATED from the second. This is exact through geometry
shaders, so KHR-GL33.transform_feedback.query_geometry_* pass; the CPU
accounting delta remains the fallback for backends without the feature.
GL_SAMPLES_PASSED / GL_ANY_SAMPLES_PASSED(_CONSERVATIVE) now work: every
app draw between Begin/EndQuery is wrapped in a slot of a host-reset
occlusion query pool (precise counts when occlusionQueryPrecise is
granted), and the result flush ends any active render pass before
submitting, waits, sums the slots and recycles them. ANY_* targets
report the boolean form; GL_QUERY_COUNTER_BITS and GL_CURRENT_QUERY
answer for the occlusion targets, and deleting an active query releases
its slot. Draw-time depth/stencil state also honors attachment absence:
a framebuffer without a depth (stencil) attachment behaves as if that
test always passes, even when a packed depth-stencil image is attached
through only one half (verify_partial_attachments.*).
glReadPixels final conversion honors GL_CLAMP_READ_COLOR (default
GL_FIXED_ONLY): fixed-point normalized color buffers clamp to [0,1] on
read - visible for SNORM attachments, whose negative values previously
leaked through (texture_size_promotion SNORM cases). True float formats
stay unclamped unless the mode is GL_TRUE; GetTexImage is unaffected.
The depth-stencil ReadPixels core (per-aspect copies + CPU repack) is
now shared, and glGetTexImage serves GL_DEPTH_COMPONENT /
GL_DEPTH_STENCIL / GL_STENCIL_INDEX queries of depth textures with it
instead of rejecting every non-color aspect
(packed_depth_stencil.verify_get_tex_image.* now passes).
glReadPixels now serves GL_DEPTH_COMPONENT, GL_DEPTH_STENCIL and
GL_STENCIL_INDEX from the read framebuffer's depth/stencil attachment:
per-aspect vkCmdCopyImageToBuffer copies (4-byte-aligned stencil region)
with CPU repacking into GL_FLOAT / GL_UNSIGNED_SHORT / GL_UNSIGNED_INT /
GL_UNSIGNED_INT_24_8 / GL_FLOAT_32_UNSIGNED_INT_24_8_REV /
GL_UNSIGNED_BYTE layouts, honoring pack state and pixel-pack buffers.
GL_DEPTH_STENCIL_ATTACHMENT parameter queries follow the spec's combined
rules: differing depth/stencil attachment images (or a lone half) fail
with GL_INVALID_OPERATION, as does GL_FRAMEBUFFER_ATTACHMENT_COMPONENT_TYPE
on the combined name. packed_depth_stencil.verify_parameters.* and
verify_read_pixels.depth24_stencil8 now pass.
Second stage of GL 3.0 transform feedback: captured draws now write real
data.
- Device setup enables the VK_EXT_transform_feedback feature when present
and loads the bind/begin/end entry points.
- Captured draws compile an XfbCapture program variant whose last
vertex-processing stage gets XfbBuffer/XfbStride/Offset decorations from
the program's resolved varyings (a new spirv-opt pass). A captured
gl_Position is mirrored into a dedicated output written before every
OpReturn - or before every OpEmitVertex in a geometry stage - ahead of
the position fixup, so the captured value is the shader's own pre-remap
position.
- DrawArrays/DrawElements wrap the draw in Begin/EndTransformFeedbackEXT;
a small counter buffer resumes the append position across draws within
one glBeginTransformFeedback (fresh Begin starts at the bound offsets).
- Capture targets are promoted to persistently-mapped host-coherent GPU
storage (persistent-map storage now also carries the transform feedback
usage), so MapBuffer/GetBufferSubData read the captured bytes after the
fence wait glEndTransformFeedback now performs.
- Draw-mode/feedback-mode validation defers to the geometry shader's
output primitive when one is present, and glGetBooleanv reports
GL_TRANSFORM_FEEDBACK_ACTIVE/PAUSED so dEQP's per-case state reset can
unwind an active capture.
KHR-GL33: transform_feedback capture_vertex_*/capture_geometry_*/
discard_*/draw_xfb and clip_distance.coverage now pass; queries
(PRIMITIVES_WRITTEN) and gl_ClipDistance capture remain.
Vulkan has no LINE_LOOP topology and the frontend used to reject the mode
with GL_INVALID_OPERATION, which is itself non-conformant (several KHR-GL33
transform_feedback tests draw line loops and expect no error). DrawArrays,
DrawElements and DrawElementsBaseVertex now rewrite the draw into an
indexed GL_LINE_STRIP whose synthesized uint32 index list revisits the
first vertex, delivered through the client-memory index path (a new
forceClientMemory flag keeps a bound element-array buffer from hijacking
the synthesized pointer). Entry points without the rewrite degrade to an
open line strip instead of a triangle list.
BlitFramebuffer's color path asserted that the read framebuffer's source
attachment is a texture; a renderbuffer source (packed_depth_stencil.blit
color checks) aborted the process. Materialize pending clears through the
renderbuffer path for both source and destination, as ReadPixels already
does.
A cached RenderPassEntry bakes renderbuffer clear payloads inline into its
pendingClearAttachments, and that list outlives the clear's consumption at
pass begin (loadOp CLEAR). Every subsequent draw that reused the entry while
its pass was still active replayed the stale clear through
vkCmdClearAttachments, wiping the color and depth of everything drawn so far
in the pass.
Texture-keyed clears already re-checked the clear manager before clearing;
do the same for inline renderbuffer payloads: only clear while the
renderbuffer clear is still actually pending, and take the live payload so a
newer glClear's values win.
On lavapipe this takes KHR-GL33.shaders.fragdepth.* from 0/18 to 18/18; the
same defect hit any renderbuffer-FBO case with several draws per pass.
With no GL_ELEMENT_ARRAY_BUFFER bound, the IndexBufferView byte offset is a
raw client pointer (desktop drivers accept client-memory indices and the GL
CTS relies on this even in core contexts). UploadAndBindIndexBuffer used to
assert-crash the process there; it now snapshots the client index data into
a transient per-frame slice and binds that, matching how client-memory
vertex attributes are already streamed.
Fixes the process abort in KHR-GL33.transform_feedback.capture_* and every
other mustpass case that draws with client-side index arrays.
- every render pass declared colorAttachmentCount=8 (the full GL draw-buffer
slot span) with trailing VK_ATTACHMENT_UNUSED references, and Adreno
configures its per-pixel render-backend/export path from the DECLARED
count - so every fragment of every pass paid an 8-render-target export
cost; this was the bulk of the 1.5x per-pixel gap against
MobileGlues+ANGLE on the same Qualcomm driver (their subpasses declare
exactly the used span)
- measured on Adreno 650 / MC 26.2 / 1440x3044: total GPU frame time
11.9 -> 7.5 ms (-37%, now below ANGLE's 7.87 ms), the single-quad
swapchain blit pass alone 1.26 -> 0.40 ms, steady in-world FPS 82.8 -> 123
under the standard cooled-start protocol, matching the
MobileGlues+ANGLE+system-Vulkan benchmark of 123.8
- trailing UNUSED references are popped before the subpass is built (the
entry's colorAttachmentCount and every pipeline's colour-blend span follow
it); interior GL_NONE holes keep their slots so fragment-output locations
still line up
- the pipeline-side fragmentOutputMask check downgrades from assert to a
debug log: an output at a location past the trimmed span is discarded,
which is GL's defined behaviour for a draw buffer set to GL_NONE
- viewport, scissor, blend constants, depth bias, line width and the six
stencil parameters were re-emitted unconditionally for EVERY draw (~1500
vkCmdSet* per frame in MC 26.2, where ANGLE emits a handful), costing CPU
record time and GPU command-processor work for values that almost never
change between draws
- a recording-scoped shadow now drops any vkCmdSet* whose values match what
the command buffer already holds; valid because every PipelineFactory
pipeline declares the same eight dynamic states, so set values persist
across those binds
- the shadow resets at every command-buffer (re)begin (dynamic state does
not survive the boundary) and after binding the blit or depth-mipmap
pipelines, whose narrower dynamic sets make the untouched states undefined
and whose raw viewport/scissor writes bypass the shadow
- a draw whose sampled texture needs out-of-pass work (deferred clear
materialization or a sampled-layout transition) used to end the active
render pass - a full-target store+reload on a tiler - even when the only
ordering the work needs is 'before this draw'; MC 26.2 clears an overlay
texture every frame and samples it mid-pass, splitting the main scene pass
once per frame for nothing
- every frame slot now carries a second primary command buffer, submitted
strictly AHEAD of the frame command buffer in the same vkQueueSubmit; when
the open recording has not referenced the image yet (tracked via a
recording-generation stamp on the texture resource, advanced on every
frame-command-buffer begin and stamped at every recorded reference:
attachments at BeginRenderPass/attachment-write, sampled reads per draw,
layout transitions), the clear/transition is recorded there and the active
pass stays open - ANGLE's outside-render-pass command stream, restricted
to the provably reorderable case
- mid-frame flushes and readback submits close and carry the pre stream with
the frame buffer (it must never be submitted later than the recording it
was paired with), retiring both under the same submit index; dropped
recordings (present suspension, swapchain recreation) abandon it
- MaterializePendingClearForTexture's no-active-render-pass assert now
applies only to the frame command buffer, since the pre stream records
while a pass is open on the frame buffer by design
- EGL swap semantics make the presented colour buffer's content undefined at
its next acquire (EGL_BUFFER_DESTROYED, the implementation default) and
every ancillary depth/stencil buffer's content undefined after ANY swap,
yet the default-FBO render pass reloaded both with LOAD_OP_LOAD every
frame; SwapchainObject now tracks per-image content validity (defined when
a pass stores into the attachment, invalidated at present) and the
render-pass manager turns an undefined attachment's tile load into
LOAD_OP_DONT_CARE with initialLayout=UNDEFINED, keyed into both hashes so
the cached LOAD variants cannot be hit by mistake
- the default framebuffer's depth attachment is now attached ON DEMAND: a
draw with depth test and stencil test both disabled (GL: a disabled test
neither reads nor writes its buffer), and no pending depth/stencil clear,
resolves to a depth-less pass flavour, dropping the D24S8 tile load AND
store outright - MC 26.2 renders its GUI into its own FBO and only ever
blits colour to the default framebuffer, so its swapchain pass carried a
full-screen depth round-trip for nothing
- the flavour only escalates: an active depth-full pass absorbs depth-less
draws unchanged, while a depth-using draw against a depth-less pass
resolves to an incompatible entry and splits, its depth loading DONT_CARE
(the content was undefined all along); the depth-less flavour is folded
into ComputeHash and the per-draw fast-path memo so the two flavours can
never alias
- Every storage-capable colour texture was created MUTABLE_FORMAT, and Adreno
gives up bandwidth compression on an image that may be viewed as any format in
its compatibility class. MC's main render target therefore ran uncompressed;
in a fill-bound scene that is the whole frame budget. Measured on Adreno 650,
MC 26.2, same scene and camera, device cooled to 38-40C before each run:
65.3 -> 80.9 fps (+23.9%), GPU busy ~93% in both.
- VK_KHR_image_format_list (enabled when present) fixes it without giving up
mutability: VkImageFormatListCreateInfo names the exact formats a view may
use, so the driver can keep the image compressed. The set must be exhaustive
or the result is undefined - for sampled views it is exactly what
ResolveSampledImageViewFormat can return over the three numeric domains.
- glBindImageTexture may name any compatible format, which cannot be enumerated
ahead of time, so a texture bound to an image unit gets no format list. That
is what VK_IMAGE_USAGE_STORAGE_BIT becoming on-demand is for: it makes
"unmarked" mean "will never receive an arbitrary-format storage view", which
is what makes the list sound. Removing STORAGE is worth nothing on its own
(65.4 fps, measured) - only the mutability bound pays.
- MarkStorageImageTexture runs over every collected image-unit texture before
the probe loop in PrepareStorageImageTextures, because that loop stops at the
first texture needing work and would leave the rest unmarked. The mark makes
NeedsStorageImagePreparation report true, which is what ends the render pass,
so the recreate lands outside it.
- storageUsageResolved separates "not upgraded yet" from "this format can never
carry STORAGE", so a format whose optimalTilingFeatures lack STORAGE_IMAGE
cannot ask for a recreate that will never happen. SyncTexture's cross-draw
early-out also has to break on a pending upgrade or the recreate never runs.
- An upgrade recreates the image and carries its contents forward through
PreserveTextureContentsOnRecreate, which submits its own command buffer and
waits. Whatever the frame already recorded into the old image is still
unsubmitted, so that copy would read pre-frame content and this frame's
rendering into the texture would be lost - exactly the render-target-then-
image-unit case. PrepareStorageImageTextures now flushes first; it takes the
FrameData rather than a command buffer because the flush retires the current
one, and drops the sampled-descriptor-set memo that described it.