Files
MobileGL/docs/Disaggregated/notes/p7/device-window-1/E0-attribution/divergent-cases.md
T
swung0x48 4f2d4c4e83 [MG_Remote, docs] (P7): CONTRACT-P7 carries wave 0's numbers, and device window #1a is on record
CONTRACT-P7: the lane counts (magma-split 73 / spawn 52 / tcp 54; full-suite 510 x 3
with one StreamLink x Magma red), the census baseline (79 abort sites over 20 files,
43 family words, 0 unmarked), the ratchet baseline (186 = p7-magma 101 / espryt 14 /
both 60 / core 11; espryt's clearable count is 9) and the @P7 count (15 sites / 4
files) replace the 待填 markers.

Device window #1a (Redmi 2f7cbe2e, APK p7w1-d260f110, reboot-clean): E0a monolith
39/39 deterministic, three below threshold on monolith itself (create-indirect,
1.21.11 main-menu, iris-photon - Adreno refuses its pipelines with VK_ERROR_UNKNOWN);
E0a inproc: OpenRA 0.976494 (run-ahead) / E1 lockstep 0.988998 - both historical
numbers were OpenRA, and its client log shows a TextureResources verb answered from
caps generation 0 (package F1); 26.3 / create-* SIGSEGV in the replayer's memcpy on
BOTH backends and with the persistent-map push off (package X1); iterationt x2 die
by name on Magma:mipmap-shader-format-or-shape (package B); bsl-esc-menu hits
scudo OOM under inproc. Gate 3's denominator is 36; run-ahead and present credit
are off the suspect list.
2026-09-22 14:49:42 -04:00

36 lines
4.9 KiB
Markdown
Executable File
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# E0 · 分歧 case 名单(本窗口最重要的产出)
E0a:39 例 × {monolith, inproc} × DirectVulkan × `--use-pbuffer` × 1 遍,APK `p7w1-d260f110`(`apk.sha256`),reboot-clean,`svc power stayon usb`。两臂各 39/39 回放完成;两臂所有有结果的 case 都逐位确定(`ssim vs first = 1.0`,E0b 的 3 遍确定性在 E1 上补做了 OpenRA 一遍——同样逐位相同)。
## 结论一句话
**inproc 对 monolith 的分歧 = 1 个像素分歧 case + 6 个进程死亡 case;36 个分母 case 里其余 29 个与 monolith 同读数**(`ssim vs golden` 之差 < 0.0005,都在阈值内)。
## 名单
| case | monolith | inproc(ARMED) | inproc(lockstep,E1) | 判定 | 归属 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| `OpenRA` | **1.000000**(mismatch 0) | **0.976493989**(14658 px) | **0.988997893** | 像素分歧,**逐位确定**,两种模式都分歧、幅度随模式变 | **caps generation 0 的家族发射丢失**:client 日志第 6 行 `the server does not consume MGPipe subsystem 0x400 (TextureResources) ... callMask=0x0, caps generation 0` 出现在 `CapsMirror generation 1 adopted` **之前**——一条纹理族 verb 在首个 CapsSnapshot 之前被判「server 不消费,走 legacy pull」,server 从没收到那条记录;diff 图只有特定 sprite / 建筑错、背景全对。lockstep 丢得少(client 逐 verb 等待,snapshot 更早到)所以 0.989 > 0.976。**两个历史观测值 0.976494 / 0.988998 都是 OpenRA**,分别是 ARMED 与 lockstep。→ wave 2 **F1**(`MG_Remote/Client/CapsMirror.cpp:137-151` 在 placeholder 上作答) |
| `improved-transparency-minecraft-26.3` | pass | **SIGSEGV** | SIGSEGV | GL 线程 `__memcpy_aarch64_nt` 从 `libtrace_replay_runner.so` 写进映射缓冲,`SEGV_ACCERR`、页对齐地址 | **与后端无关**(E4a:DirectGLES inproc 同样 SEGV)、**与 persistent-map push 无关**(E4b:`MOBILEGL_IPC_PERSISTENT_BLOCK_KB=0` 仍 SEGV)→ wave 2 **X1** |
| `minecraft-1.21.1-neoforge-create-instancing-in-world` | pass | **SIGSEGV** | SIGSEGV | 同上形状 | 同上 → X1 |
| `minecraft-1.21.1-neoforge-create-indirect-in-world` | 0.000005(monolith 就红) | SIGSEGV | — | 同上形状 | ID-P7-4 已排除;崩溃形状同 X1,修好后照常记录 |
| `minecraft-1.21.4-fabric-iris-iterationt-in-world` | pass | **`Fatal{UnmigratedVerb, "Magma:mipmap-shader-format-or-shape"}`**(apply 线程) | 同 | 具名拒绝,确定 | → wave 2 **B**(`WireFramebuffer.inc` 的 wire mip 路径;lavapipe 上绿,Adreno 缺某格式的 BLIT 特性) |
| `minecraft-1.21.4-fabric-iris-iterationt-nodsa-in-world` | pass | 同上 | — | 同上 | → B |
| `minecraft-1.21.4-fabric-iris-bsl-esc-menu-854` | pass | **SIGABRT** `Scudo ERROR: internal map failure (Out of memory)`(apply 线程) | **SIGSEGV** | 内存上限:inproc 把两个角色的 shadow 装在一个进程里 | 记录;在 spawn(两进程)臂上复测(窗口 1b)后再定归属——若 spawn 过则是 inproc 的地址空间账(P8/P11 的题材),若 spawn 也 OOM 则是 Magma 的 staging 账 |
| `minecraft-1.21.11-main-menu` | 0.164984 | 0.164984 | — | 两臂逐字相同 | trace 自身的 UBO 对齐伪差,非分离缺陷(`exclusions.md`) |
| `minecraft-1.21.4-fabric-iris-photon-v1.3b-in-world` | 0.008865 | 0.008865 | — | 两臂逐字相同 | Adreno 拒绝 photon 管线,monolith 级(`exclusions.md`) |
其余 29 个分母 case:两臂 `ssim vs golden` 之差均 < 0.0005(iris 光影 case 两臂都在 0.996–0.9995,非光影 case 两臂都 ≥ 0.9999),逐位确定。完整数据:`E0a-monolith-summary.{txt,json}`、`E0a-inproc-summary.{txt,json}`、`../E1-lockstep/E1-summary.{txt,json}`。
## E2(credit 1 vs 3)与 E0b(3 遍确定性)
按 runbook §5 的判别,E1「不变」时 E2 不必跑:run-ahead 与 credit 整条线出局(OpenRA 在 lockstep 下也分歧,且崩溃 case 在 lockstep 下也崩)。E0b 的 3 遍确定性只在 OpenRA 上有意义,E1 已给出第二遍逐位相同(lockstep 臂内);ARMED 下的三遍在 F1 修复后的复测里一起做。
## E3(caps 比对)
已在 OpenRA 上做:inproc 臂 `answering a PLACEHOLDER` 0 条、`does not consume MGPipe subsystem` **1 条**(0x400,generation 0)、`CapsMirror generation 1..5 adopted`(callMask 0x3fff00000460 → 0x3fff00000470)、`run-ahead ARMED` 1 条;monolith 臂无 wire 行。`GL_UNIFORM_BUFFER_OFFSET_ALIGNMENT` 行两臂都没打(该日志行不在这条 trace 的路径上)。判别落在「能力协商」:与 runbook 表的预测一致。
## 与出口门 3 的关系
分母 36(`exclusions.md`)。今天 inproc 对 monolith:**29 同、1 像素分歧(F1)、5 死(X1 ×2 + B ×2 + bsl 内存)**,另 1(create-indirect)在分母外但同为 X1 形状。wave 2 的 F1 / X1 / B 三个包各自落地后按 `CONTRACT-P7.md` §7.2 复测(3 遍 + monolith 同会话对照)。